[quote name='mang9432']so here's one for you. I have (had) a sealed reprint of Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne that i bought on amazon. This is actually the second time I've bought this game, and decided that i'm never gonna play it. I got suckered into buying it both times. So, I'm an active goozex member, and the game gets 1000 points on goozex. So I put it up and traded it away.
Today I received neutral feedback saying this...
The user xxxxxxx has reported neutral feedback on the transaction for the game Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne.
Feedback:
I requested a "Full Package", but received only a "Disc + Manual"
Comment:
If I wanted a reprint I would have bought one from Amazon for $30. Stop screwing people to save a few bucks.
So, i disputed the feedback. There's no separate listing for different print runs of a game (save for a few greatest hits versions... etc) But this game has one version on goozex. I just feel that this guy is being a little picky about his goozex experience, when he should have been happy to receive a sealed game instead of some of the shit cases / manuals / discs i've received from time to time.[/QUOTE]
As far as I can tell you should be good in the dispute. As you already mentioned there is no separate listing for the original vs reprint for Nocturn (besides the fact that most people probably wouldn't be able to tell the difference anyway). He requested full package , he got sealed , which is more than enough. It wasn't a special edition where it was missing something that would make it further complete so there was no foul. Only other thing I could mention would be to offer a return/trade cancellation to him , but as I mentioned he techincally got what he requested so you should be fine.
Keep us updated on how the G-Team handels it.
[quote name='depascal22']That's why you list disc + manual for any games that had limited editions or extra soundtracks, plushies, etc. Then again, you might never get matched.
Got a +5 today from a newer member. Sent him Ratchet & Clank Size Matters from the 3000 bundle. Listed it as Disc + Manual and the game was damn near cherry and the manual didn't even have a dogear on it. He hasn't responded to my PM but it'll either be laziness or something about it not having a case.[/QUOTE]
Good points about the soundtrack , I forgot that the first printing of Nocturn had that. As I mentioned before though , the listing for Nocturn on the site makes no mention about requiring the soundtrack , so he might have a hard sell convincing them to side with him. Although the tip about listing non-complete "special" editions like that as disk+manual or disk only still holds true. This is kinda a grey area though.
As far as the +5 for Size Matters , I've pretty much resigned myself to always getting a +5 for any disk+manual or disk only games. I don't know what people expect in that situation , but it seems to be the norm.