Official User Feedback/Rating Topic [Part 1]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Who did you trade with? caseyryback
What did you get? players guide
What did you give? players guide
How long did the deal take? days
Were they friendly? y
Easy to work with? y
Quick to respond? y
Would you deal with them again? y
Shipping Method Used?
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
 
Who did you trade with? MisterRaven
What did you get? Mega Man Battle Network (GBA) and Suikoden 3 (PS2)
What did you give? R.A.D. (PS2) and BG&E (PS2)
How long did the deal take? Day to PM + shipping time
Were they friendly? Yup
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Indeed
Would you deal with them again? Sure
Shipping Method Used? Priority Mail with Delviery Confirmation
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Cool guy. Look forward to trading again in the future.
 
Who did you trade with? sm04as
What did you get? P.N. 03
What did you give? Pikmin
How long did the deal take? One week
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS w/DC
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Good communication. Easy trade.
 
Who did you trade with? Dead of Knight
What did you get? SFA3 and SA guide
What did you give? cash
How long did the deal take? days
Were they friendly? y
Easy to work with? y
Quick to respond? y
Would you deal with them again? y
Shipping Method Used?
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)?10
Additional Comments? thanks. Now I may finally get some playtime out of Alpha 3
 
Who did you trade with? CaseyRyback
What did you get? money
What did you give? SFA3 and SA guide (DC)
How long did the deal take? days
Were they friendly? y
Easy to work with? y
Quick to respond? y
Would you deal with them again? already have dealt with him twice
Shipping Method Used? media mail
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? check
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)?10
Additional Comments? This guy is an awesome trader and I hope we do business again.
 
Who did you trade with? goldengraham
What did you get? Devil May Cry 2
What did you give? Road Kill GC
How long did the deal take? a few days
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? N/A
Shipping Price (If not included) N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)?10
Additional Comments? Graham trades like a pro.
 
Who did you trade with? yeldarb367
What did you get? Pikmin (GC) Sealed
What did you give? PN03 (GC) Sealed
How long did the deal take? A few days to talk it out, a couple to ship
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS First Class w/DC
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Nice trader - easy to work with. Game looks so nice! Thank you for the game!
 
Who did you trade with - Mustang O-Line 75
What did you get - Zoocube (GCN)
What did you give - $10 paypal
How long did the deal take - about a week
Were they friendly - very
Easy to work with - very
Quick to respond - very
Would you deal with them again - in a second
Shipping Method Used - first class usps w/ delivery confirmation
Shipping Price (If not included) - $.00
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell) - paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10) - 10/10
Additional Comments? - thanks!
 
Who did you trade with? siamesellama
What did you get? Shining Soul (GBA, new)
What did you give? Time Splitters 2 (GCN, new)
How long did the deal take? About a week.
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS with DC
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Good trade.
 
Who did you trade with? Zmonkay
What did you get? sealed rez
What did you give? viewtiful joe(used, like new) + (armored core 3, sealed/new)
How long did the deal take? a few days
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? sure
Quick to respond? yep
Would you deal with them again? absolutely
Shipping Method Used? usps first class with dc
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Zmonkay is a kickass trader, i hope he likes his games.
 
Who did you trade with? wibsisa
What did you get? Monster Rancher Advance (sealed)
What did you give? Shining Soul (sealed)
How long did the deal take? 3 days
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? absolutely
Shipping Method Used? usps priority mail with dc
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Great deal, would love to trade again
 
Who did you trade with? hunter_d
What did you get? 10$
What did you give? Soul Calibur (DC)
How long did the deal take? Week
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? absolutely
Shipping Method Used? usps priority mail with dc
Shipping Price (If not included)? Included
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Green MO
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Worked well, thanks!
 
Who did you trade with? craven_fiend
What did you get? Super Smash Brothers Melee
What did you give? Final Destination 2, Timesplitters 2, and Silent Hill2
How long did the deal take? Week
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? absolutely
Shipping Method Used? usps priority mail with dc
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Worked well, thanks!
 
Who did you trade with? Mustang O-Line 75
What did you get? Mega Man Battle Network 3 Blue
What did you give? Spy Hunter 2 & $5
How long did the deal take? 1 day to PM, 1 day to trade
Were they friendly? Very much so
Easy to work with? Yup
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Absolutely
Shipping Method Used? N/A - We met up in person
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Cash
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Very cool guy and super easy to deal with. Highly recommended.
 
Who did you trade with? dukedynamo
What did you get? splashdown
What did you give? indiana jones
How long did the deal take? in a few minutes
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? definitely
Shipping Method Used? met up to trade
Shipping Price (If not included)? n/a
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? n/a
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10!!!
Additional Comments? great trader! friendly, easy to deal with and overall, a very smooth trade!
 
Who did you trade with? Edge
What did you get? Wario World
What did you give? RAD
How long did the deal take? about a week
Were they friendly? very
Easy to work with? very
Quick to respond? exceptionaly
Would you deal with them again? most definitely
Shipping Method Used? first class
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? great trader, recommended
 
Who did you trade with? spidey
What did you get? 6$
What did you give? Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles Magnets
How long did the deal take? 1 week
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS First Class
Shipping Price (If not included)? Included
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? non-cc PayPal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Hi.
 
Who did you trade with? DriftChamp
What did you get? Metal Arms (Xbox)
What did you give? Megaman X7 (PS2)
How long did the deal take? Maybe 1-2 days
Were they friendly? Very
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Definitely
Shipping Method Used? USPS Priority w/ tracking #
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Great trade, good communication!
 
Who did you trade with? varsitygamer
What did you get? Midway Arcade Classics (Xbox)
What did you give? Bomberman Generations (GC)
How long did the deal take? 1 or 2 days
Were they friendly? Very
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Of course
Shipping Method Used? UPS
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10+
Additional Comments? Great trader.. went out of his way to ship UPS even though he didn't have to. We both got what we wanted!
 
Who did you trade with? emagius
What did you get? Advance Wars (GBA)
What did you give? $12
How long did the deal take? couple hours
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? PayPal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Well packed, and complete, down to the cardboard CART holder from the GBA box. Shipping from the USA-->Canada in ~ 1 week. Thanks.
 
Who did you trade with? doraemonkerpal
What did you get? Indiana Jones and the Emperor's Tomb
What did you give? Splashdown
How long did the deal take? 5-10 minutes
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? absolutely
Shipping Method Used? exchange in person
Shipping Price (If not included)? n/a
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? n/a
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? cool and friendly; will definitely trade with in the future.
 
Who did you trade with? Crewser
What did you get? Shenmue II (sealed)
What did you give? Grabbed by the Ghoulies (sealed)
How long did the deal take? a couple of days
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? of course
Shipping Method Used? 1st class w/ delivery confirmation
Shipping Price (If not included)? $2.30
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? n/a
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? super-quick shipment; very smooth transaction; looking forward to more trades in the future.
 
Who did you trade with? Coolcps
What did you get? $32
What did you give? Shenmue 2, Summoner 2, The Bouncer
How long did the deal take? 2 days
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? very
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS Priority
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
 
Who did you trade with? Game Hunter
What did you get? $24
What did you give? Secret Weapons over Normandy, Dead to Right (Xbox)
How long did the deal take? 2 days
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS Priority
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
 
Who did you trade with? Dustin Echoes
What did you get? $20
What did you give? Maximo vs the army of Zin
How long did the deal take? 2 days
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yep
Shipping Method Used? USPS First Class
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
 
Who did you trade with? lain21us
What did you get? Skies of Arcadia Legends
What did you give? Guilty Gear X-2
How long did the deal take? less than a week
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS first class
Shipping Price (If not included)? $2.30
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Class act all the way, quick responses, quick shipping. Great first trading experience for me.
 
Who did you trade with? Squirms
What did you get? Guilty Gear X2
What did you give? Skies of Arcadia Legends GC
How long did the deal take? a few business days
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS first class w/ DC
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Great trader, a valuable addition to CAG's trading community
 
Who did you trade with? Akuma
What did you get? $15 shipped
What did you give? Batman:Rise of Sin Tzu-Kelly Slater Pro Surfer (both Xbox, new)
How long did the deal take? 2 weeks
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS First Class
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Money Order
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Sorry the feedback took so long, this one slipped through the cracks. I was just cleaning my inbox and I saw one your PMs from the trade.
 
Who did you trade with? mombbsmj
What did you get? Prince of Persia GBA + Sonic Battle
What did you give? Shining Soul II
How long did the deal take? several emails + shipping time
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? most definitely
Shipping Method Used? USPS
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? I have made another trade with this user
 
Who did you trade with? Lain21US
What did you get? $16
What did you give? NHL Hitz Pro and F1 2002
How long did the deal take? 2 days
Were they friendly? Extremely
Easy to work with? Very
Quick to respond? Superb
Would you deal with them again? Without a doubt
Shipping Method Used? Media Mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? Included
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Wonderful trade. Thanks again for the deal. I hope everything works out well for you.
Matthew
 
Who did you trade with? mombbsmj
What did you get? Sonic Pinball GBA + Fifa 2004 GBA
What did you give? Demi Kid Light + Dark version
How long did the deal take? several emails + shipping time
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? most definitely
Shipping Method Used? USPS
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? I will if I have another chance
 
Who did you trade with? BigHow
What did you get? $8
What did you give? Aliens vs Predator Extinction
How long did the deal take? 3 days
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Superb
Quick to respond? Wonderful
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? 1st class
Shipping Price (If not included)? Included
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? PayPal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Thanks for the tremendous trade. I hope that you enjoy the game.
Take Care,
Matthew
 
Who did you trade with? ksuwild25
What did you get? Boktai (GBA)
What did you give? Robin Hood: DOTC (PS2)
How long did the deal take? 1 day to PM + shipping time
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Sure
Shipping Method Used? 1st Class Mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Cool guy, very easy to work with.
 
Who did you trade with? dj_paxis
What did you get? Rainbow Six 3 (xbox) and Gladius (xbox, sealed)
What did you give? LotR Return of the king (DVD, widescreen), Shenmue II (xbox), and Morrowind (xbox, PH)
How long did the deal take? 4 days
Were they friendly? Definitely
Easy to work with? Very easy
Quick to respond? Very quick
Would you deal with them again? Definitely
Shipping Method Used? USPS priority mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? $4.30
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 11
Additional Comments? Great guy, trade with him if you get the chance :D
 
Who did you trade with? dj_paxis
What did you get? Bomberman Generations (GC)
What did you give? Midway Arcade Treasures (XBox)
How long did the deal take? 1 or 2 days
Were they friendly? Very
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Definately
Shipping Method Used? UPS
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 11
Additional Comments? Awesome guy, quick to respond, quick to send, overall a pleasure to deal with :D
 
Who did you trade with? Linkinprime
What did you get? Dark Angel
What did you give? F-Zero (GBA)
How long did the deal take? 5 days with a holiday weekend in there
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? most definitely
Shipping Method Used? USPS with DC
Shipping Price (If not included)? n/a, straight trade
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? n/a
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Super quick to respond and ship.
 
Who did you trade with? crewser
What did you get? Wild Arms 3 - sealed
What did you give? MLB Slugfest 2004 - sealed
How long did the deal take? about a week
Were they friendly? yes!
Easy to work with? very!
Quick to respond? yes!
Would you deal with them again? damn right i would!
Shipping Method Used? first class w/delivery confirmation
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10+
Additional Comments? Thanks again for initiating and completing this wonderful trade!!
 
Who did you trade with? sm04as
What did you get? Zelda Collectors Disc
What did you give? La Pucelle Tactics - sealed
How long did the deal take? about a week
Were they friendly? very
Easy to work with? very
Quick to respond? very
Would you deal with them again? yes i would
Shipping Method Used? first class w/ dc
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? A+, great trader! Thanks again for the trade!!
 
Who did you trade with? waxHead
What did you get? Culdcept (PO), PN 03 (sealed), and some cash!
What did you give? La Pucelle Tactics & Jedi Outcast (XBX) - both sealed
How long did the deal take? less than a week
Were they friendly? yes!
Easy to work with? yes!
Quick to respond? yes!
Would you deal with them again? yes!!
Shipping Method Used? first class w/ DC
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10!!!
Additional Comments? Great, last minute transaction! Thanks again!
 
Who did you trade with? dj_paxis
What did you get? Gundam: Federation vs. Zeon
What did you give? $10
How long did the deal take? a few hours and a few days for shipping
Were they friendly? Very much so
Easy to work with? Absolutly
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Of course
Shipping Method Used? UPS ground
Shipping Price (If not included)? included
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? A great seller, hope all are like him.
 
Who did you trade with? btantra
What did you get? Demi Kids-Light and Dark
What did you give? Fifa Soccer 2004 & Sonic Pinball
How long did the deal take? few days start to finish
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? most definately
Shipping Method Used? usps 1st class
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Great trader. 2nd trade and the games have come in perfect condition both times. I'm sure we'll be trading again hopefully sooner than later.
 
Who did you trade with? deathcabforcutie
What did you get? Enclave
What did you give? MK: DA
How long did the deal take? couple dasy
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? usps
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? good communication
 
Who did you trade with? chickenhawk
What did you get? forever kingdom
What did you give? street fighter ex3
How long did the deal take? week
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? fc w/ dc#
Shipping Price (If not included)? included
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? trade
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? AAA+
 
Who did you trade with? dbiersdorf
What did you get? used Mario & Luigi, Pokemon Yellow for GB
What did you give? new Bionicle GC and new Oddworld for GBA
How long did the deal take? 3 1/2 weeks
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? not immediate, but within a day or so
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS in regular envelope
Shipping Price (If not included)? n/a
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? n/a
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 8.5
Additional Comments? Dbiersdorf was a nice guy--but did have a bit of a delay in initial shipping; then the wrong amount of postage was put on, leading to further delay. Still, Dan was very nice and did deliver what was promised in the end :)
 
Who did you trade with? magilacudy
What did you get? ChuChu Rocket GBA
What did you give? Gunvalkyrie Xbox
How long did the deal take? 2 days
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? 1st class with conf.
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Great trade. Highly recommended.
 
Who did you trade with? sm04as
What did you get? Smuggler's Run
What did you give? Spyhunter
How long did the deal take? not long
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? definately
Shipping Method Used? USPS-1st class and media
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Very friendly, great communication. I hope to deal with again in the near future.
 
Who did you trade with? Howeraing
What did you get? N/A
What did you give? Gundam Fed vs Zeon, Lunar Legend and Golden Sun
How long did the deal take? 1 day for the first, 2 for the second
Were they friendly? Very
Easy to work with? Very easy deal
Quick to respond? Responded quick, paid fast too!
Would you deal with them again? YES.
Shipping Method Used? UPS
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10+
Additional Comments? Great buyer. Prompt payments from a nice guy are greatly appreciated!
 
Who did you trade with? drfrielgood
What did you get? Wario Ware Inc (GC)
What did you give? Klonoa 2 (sealed)
How long did the deal take? less than a week total
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? certainly
Shipping Method Used? USPS 1st class
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Great trader. Deal was worked out within minutes and shipped within a couple of days. Couldn't ask for a smoother trade.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
bread's done
Back
Top