I had the opportunity to play NCAA 08, demo on xbox live, and the game basically plays like last years madden 07 on PS3... the animations are not fluid, the players just snap like falling dominos into their pre set animations... however looking at the video of Allpro 2k8, the animations seem so fluid.. like when the player turns, he leans into the turn, the players seem more life life, whereas NCAA seem more robotic. I never liked the 2k Football games, but since Madden 07, the game haven't shown the improvements.. we'll see, but for now, I'm going to give al pro a shot.