Planet Earth: BBC version (HD DVD), $45

luvmysegadc

CAGiversary!
Feedback
1 (100%)
If anyone wants the BBC Version, it's available currently at $45 NEW and $40 USED (Standard Shipping is $2.98) @ HD DVD Boxsets (an Amazon.com store):

http://www.hddvdboxsets.com/hddvd1-387548011-B000MRAAJW-Planet_Earth_The_Complete_BBC_Series_HD_DVD.html




51BnSYgZRAL.jpg

IMG%5D
 
not sure if someone has said this but, you are not buying from the actual company/website. hdddvdboxsets.com just takes all the marketplace listings of third party sellers from amazon and puts that info into their website. from time to time you will see the prices change. i've heard alright reviews about them however
 
[quote name='Darthjer']Anybody have a quick description/summary of the difference between US and UK versions?[/quote]

The BBC version can output in 1080p, has about an extra hour of footage, and has a different narrator than the Discovery Channel version.
 
[quote name='Darthjer']Anybody have a quick description/summary of the difference between US and UK versions?[/quote]

I believe the BBC HD version is longer but it does not contain the extra features
"Planet Earth – The Future" but the US Discovery Channel has this on separate bonus 110 minutes standard def disc.
 
Wikipedia has an extensive comparison. Narrator on the US/Discovery channel version is Sigourney Weaver (this is the one that aired here, if you saw it). BBC edition has David Attenborough. Discovery channel box lists resolutions at 720p and 1080i, while BBC box lists 1080p. Whether this is because one section is 1080i but all the others is 1080p and one (Discovery) is posting the lowest/minimum available res. and the other (BBC) is only listing the highest remains to be verified.

I have the BBC version and have not checked the material in question yet. Perhaps someone here has.

There is apparently some controversy over the labeling (see wikipedia) regarding sub-sections of the disc even in the BBC version that are only 1080i and whether or not box labeling may be accurate.

Some highlights from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet_Earth_%28TV_series%29 :
A five-disc DVD boxed set of the complete series (BBCDVD1883) was released in the UK for regions 2 and 4 (PAL) on 27 November 2006. It is presented in 5.1-channel Dolby Digital surround sound and 16:9 widescreen video. The bonus features include Planet Earth Diaries (ten minutes of behind-the-scenes footage for each episode, as on their original broadcasts) and Planet Earth: The Future,[10] the three documentaries as detailed above.
2 entertain, which publishes and distributes BBC programming on DVD, produced four-disc high-definition versions of Planet Earth on Blu-ray Disc and HD DVD in the US. The boxed sets were released on 24 April 2007, just after the series ended its run on the Discovery Channel.[4] Both the Blu-ray and HD DVD versions feature 1080p transfers of the original UK broadcast, as narrated by David Attenborough — even though the US Discovery Channel broadcast featured Sigourney Weaver as its narrator. The Blu-ray set contains four single-layer BD-25 discs,[11] while the HD DVD set uses four dual-layer HD DVD-30 discs.[12] Except for a small amount of extremely hard-to-obtain footage,[13] the series was originally filmed entirely in high definition.[14] However, the high-definition releases omit the extra disc of bonus features that is present on the standard-definition boxed set.[15] The Blu-ray region B boxed set (as sold in countries such as the UK and New Zealand [16]) includes a fifth disc containing two episodes from the BBC Natural World series, "Desert Lions" and "Snow Leopard: Beyond the Myth". This extra disc balances out the loss of the bonus material from the standard definition DVD boxed sets. It is not known exactly why the standard definition and high-definition versions have this differing content but given that the Natural World content is in 1080i it is hypothesised that the Planet Earth Diaries and Planet Earth: The Future were filmed in standard definition only, and that there was an intention to avoid standard definition material where possible in the Blu-ray release. Verification of this will be required from anyone who has seen the HD broadcast version.[citation needed]

Also

The U.S. version also features a new narrator: award-winning actress and conservationist Sigourney Weaver. The Discovery Channel DVD, Blu-ray, and HD DVD release contain this new narration, but the BBC's DVD, Blu-ray and HD DVD releases in the USA feature the original version with David Attenborough as narrator. In addition, the Planet Earth Diaries segment was retitled Capturing the Shot in the Discovery Channel version. This will not air on the Canadian Discovery Channel, as it is owned by CTV and the Canadian rights were exclusively sold to CBC.[19]
 
I thought Cheapy didn't want us to use that link, since he doesn't get the referral from it, and it just steals from Amazon
 
bread's done
Back
Top