I keep saying it, but I guess I'll ask it again... why does it even matter? Whenever I read something like "member only" it comes off more like "that should be my content"...
The point is to give it away to someone who wants it and not exactly reward the first person who meets a certain criteria. If you think it should be done via PM's, replies, questions then YOU do it. If you don't care and just post it.. then let them do as they want.
Geez~