[quote name='Buuhan1']Gamefly is shit. Their stock is shit. Their shipping is shit. To pay $18 a month and not even be able to rent new titles unless you have it solely in your cart with no other games out before it releases is ridiculious. If you have money and don't care where it goes or only care about older titles then yeah, Gamefly is fine. Otherwise, you'd be better off just buying the game.
Or do the 2 game plan which you can fix to have one slot dedicated to new titles, but that's even more money you gotta put down, damn nearly $30/month after tax. 2 months of that and you could have bought that game you so desperately wanted to rent.[/QUOTE]
Gotta agree here.
$22/month is too much for two games at a time -- which ends up closer to one game at a time, when you factor in shipping times. Unless you intend to keep each game for a couple of weeks at a time (not really my idea of "renting"), it's not really worth it.
What they really need to do is ship games in your queue to you on the same day that you put a game back in the mail, not on the day that they receive it. Just log into the site, click a button that says "I just dropped it in the mail", and go. Turnaround time would instantly be cut in half to two or three days instead of four or five. This would require Gamefly to put a certain level of trust that the user isn't going to *say* a game's in the mail a day or two before it's actually there, but yeah, if the games show up a full week or more later than the customer claims to have shipped them back, slap them with a penalty fee (or revoke their return-notice privileges) and call it a day. Everyone else gets two days more playtime from each game swap -- easily an extra week or more every month.
That simple change would mean the difference between me subscribing and not.
......wasn't expecting this post to be that long, oops.