I got an e-mail back, and they're not moving. I guess I can console myself by saying I got the plushie (which I didn't want) and a great game, and it was still under $30 total. Sending it back, I'd imagine they would make me pay 2-day shipping (Prime), so I'd be out whatever money I was saving by returning it and re-purchasing it at a lower price.
Amazon prices are such a gamble. Up and down, up and down... It sounds stupid to complain about price drops, but frick! Don't they get how annoying it is to buy something and see it $10 cheaper the next day and not be able to get money back? That's absurd, frankly. Target or any other retailer would give you $10 back, no questions asked, in a situation like that, as long as you had the item and a receipt.
I'm annoyed.
Edit--More... So I clicked the "Did this e-mail resolve your issue? No" button and wrote them a rather long diatribe listing at least four reasons why I think it's totally lame that their best solution is for me to send the product back and re-purchase the exact same thing at a lower price and how other retailers, like Target, would never require such silliness.
We'll see if I get any kind of response.
My brother-in-law is friends with Jeff Bezo's barista and knows where he gets coffee. I will sit my ass down at his table and harp if I need to.
Just kidding about the Jeff Bezo thing. I don't even have a brother-in-law! I'm serious about the rest, though.

Amazon has been really bizarre lately. Their prices and deals are great (at least they satisfy me), but things just have not been working out, what with the gift cards not going through without prodding, all this strangeness with price guarantees, etc etc etc. And dang it, I'm pissed that I missed out on the Xbox Gold Box thing today, too! I would have bought Vesperia! (Not that it's their fault, but jeez louise, I'm feeling cavil, okay??)