Alright, so after the disappointment of my initial wishlist, I scrapped most of it and here are my likely cheap purchases this sale (posting just in case anyone is interested in them too):
Dead Secret - $5.99 (60% off of $14.99)
http://store.steampowered.com/app/402260/Dead_Secret/
This one is a maybe, mostly because it is VR too (you get a code to unlock the OR version with purchase it says) so I want to make sure the positive reviews aren't just people saying it's good for a VR game and not a good game overall.
Roots of Insanity - $2.44 (65% off of $6.99)
http://store.steampowered.com/app/598440/Roots_of_Insanity/
Reasonably priced horror game, quick price drop (released this April). Probably prime bundle candidate.
Radiation Island - $1.01 (66% off of $2.99)
http://store.steampowered.com/app/307940/Radiation_Island/
Probably stupid, short, and pointless, but mostly positive reviews and $1.
Dead End Road - $.74 (75% off of $2.99)
http://store.steampowered.com/app/448580/Dead_End_Road/
Positive reviews, different type of horror game and only .74 cents. The price of a NON-PREMIUM soup.
The Black Watchmen - $2.50 (75% off of $9.99)
http://store.steampowered.com/app/349220/The_Black_Watchmen/
This is an Alternate Reality Game, which is one where you interact with websites and other stuff to solve puzzles. I have horrible history with these, meaning I've bought two and never finished them and I assume those are long dead (Missing: Since January and Evidence: The Last Ritual).
Zombie Party - $1.99 (80% off of $9.99)
http://store.steampowered.com/app/384500/Zombie_Party/
Rogue like action RPG so I'm probably going to hate it, but ZOMBIES!