Hah - funny to see this bumped again. For the record, I ordered 2 and got 2 Mario's. WTF?? I understand them not wanting people to pick certain ones, but I thought I'd at least get 2 different ones!
Oh well, it's no big deal as my youngest snagged one of them for himself anyway. So now I have one on my desk and he has one to play with. I suppose if there was one I had wanted 2 of it would be Mario. Though he would have been happy with any I'm sure.