[quote name='Survivor Charlie']Oh come on, almost any game that over 10 years old is going to be somewhat rare new.
Rare might be an accepted term (I argue that point myself... rare in and of itself suggests that the game had very few copies made) but it doesn't make it right. And again, it's not HARD to find either, but rather expensive. I've seen half a dozen FFVIIs "in the wild" this week alone.
And again, you're one remake/rerelease from the market crashing and your investment in the game looking very stupid. Ask the fools who shelled out over $100 for Final Fantasy III on the SNES.[/QUOTE]
I had to edit my posts (both the previous and this one) several times, so please re-read the previous one (the part about Theme Park, since it brings up your point a bit) because I kept adding some stuff.
You mean a FFIII like this:
http://cgi.ebay.com/FINAL-FANTASY-I...ryZ62053QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem
Sold pretty well to me, and it's not even a new copy. Although, the value is about the BEP for when this game actually came out. I believe it came out at $89.99, but I'm not going to look it up. Also, that $89.99 was for a new copy. This was around $90 for a used one. If you take inflation and other factors into consideration (re-releases, etc.), then it's actually worth much less than when it came out.
I think the definition of RARE used by the general gaming community is best defined as a game (or gaming item) which carries value at least to its previous MSRP level and has a demand level above average within the community itself. As the increase in demand and scarcity of newer copies (and sometimes copies in general) rises, the value of the game (or gaming item) should go above and beyond previous MSRP levels. This isn't a focused definition, I just kind of threw it out there
Look at Karaoke Revolution for all systems. That game was being clearanced out like mad around me, but I never once bit on any of them. Now, they went (specifically the PS2 versions) from their clearance prices to around $60 (I think this was MSRP) or higher with a mic. The game is not HTF, rare or whatever term you want to use, but I think its popularity jumped when Rock Band came out.