[quote name='Ronin317']Rare has nothing to do with how many copies are pressed overall,
it has to do mostly with demand. Despite the millions of FFVIIs floating around, there is a solid demand still for the product, thus making it rare. You also have to factor in the number of asshats that abused the shit out of every disc they've ever owned, and FFVII was the first RPG and sometimes first cd-based game they owned, therefore they didn't care for it. I worked at EB when it came out and a few years after, and my buddy runs a used store now, and the amount of people that come in with just a stack of discs to sell is ridiculous. I'm betting a good 10-15% of the original black label and 15-20% GH copies have been trashed at this point. Most don't have cases, and even more don't have instructions. Thus, the collectors market for the product deems it rare.
I saw far more beat-up PSX systems and games in the 2-3 years following it's release than I ever saw in the entire runs of NES, SNES, and Genesis combined. People just beat on that system.[/QUOTE]
You simply can't say it has "nothing to do with how many copies are pressed", you and everyone else knows that is technically impossible as supply/demand ONLY work together. We know about the demand for FF7, the problem is the supply was just fine for years, until eBay exploding and Square started talking like there would never be a FF7 remake, the "demand" went up.
However my point is the "demand" is mostly from EBAY hoarders who speculated correctly that the price of FF7 would go up if they hoarded all the copies because of the lack of remake potential.
I also agree that CDs definitely took abuse.
But as always you can't ignore supply OR demand, they both exist.
in this case its a "false rare" because the supply and demand were balanced forever, then magically one day it became rare. And that "magic" was greedy hoarders.
Atlus games are an example of the opposite. There is mild demand for the games new, but they only print limited copies, HOARDERS on EBAY snatch them all up, then the games get good reviews and suddenly everyone who was like "oh ill buy the GH version" can't get a copy because the games never go GH and all the new sealed copies have been EBAY hoarded.
So the demand and supply in the case of atlus are manipulated by dirty capitalistic tricks, exactly like the tricks used to control the price of milk/meat/oil etc...
Its shennanigans. There is no justifiable reason why people should be cock blocked from buying a sealed copy of a CD based game.