The Official GOTY 2010 Thread

IRHari

CAGiversary!
Feedback
3 (100%)
So what is your Game Of The Year /cag/?

and remember people these are opinions and not fact.

Best game of the Year:

Best FPS of the Year:

Best TPS of the Year:

Best RPG of the Year:

Best Puzzle game of the Year:

Best Adventure game of the Year:

Best Simulation game of the Year:

Best Strategy game of the Year:

Best Indie game of the Year:

Best MMO of the Year:

Best Racing game of the Year:

Best Sports game of the Year:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hate to break it to you, but 2000-2010 is actually 11 years. You're about a year late with this thread (unless you want to consider 2001-2010)
 
Best game of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best FPS of the Year: Bioshock 2 (Haven't played Reach yet, and Black Ops doesn't cut it.)

Best RPG of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best Puzzle game of the Year: Osmos (iPhone version came out this year.)

Best Adventure game of the Year: Amnesia: The Dark Descent

Best Strategy game of the Year: Starcraft 2

Best Indie game of the Year: Amnesia: The Dark Descent

Best MMO of the Year: World of Warcraft: Cataclysm

I excluded genres that I didn't play any games of this year.
 
Best game of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best FPS of the Year: Halo Reach

Best RPG of the Year: Mass Effect 2


Didn't play anything in the other listed genres that I can recall. At least not 2010 games.
 
Best game of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best FPS of the Year: Halo: Reach

Best TPS of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best RPG of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best Adventure game of the Year: Assassin's Creed Brotherhood

Best Indie game of the Year: Minecraft

Best Racing game of the Year: NFS: Hot Pursuit


And I'm throwing in...

Best Handheld Game: Pokemon SoulSilver
 
CAG really ought to have some sort of voting system put together, with stats - maybe something using the wishlist system.

Best game of the Year: 999 (DS)

Best RPG of the Year: SMT - Strange Journey (DS)

Best Puzzle game of the Year: Professor Layton and the Unwound Future (DS)

Best Adventure game of the Year: 999 (DS)

Best Simulation game of the Year: Trauma Team (Wii)
 
Best game of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best FPS of the Year: Halo: Reach

Best TPS of the Year: Alan Wake

Best RPG of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best Puzzle game of the Year: N/A

Best Adventure game of the Year: Enslaved

Best Simulation game of the Year: N/A

Best Strategy game of the Year: Knights in the Nightmare

Best Indie game of the Year:

Best MMO of the Year: Anything but WoW

Best Racing game of the Year:

Best Sports game of the Year: Madden 2011
 
Best game of the Year: Deadly Premonition (runners up: Enslaved, Majin, SMG2, Costume Quest, 999, Minerva's Den)

Best FPS of the Year: Bioshock 2 Minerva's Den

Best TPS of the Year: Dead Rising 2 (third person action game with guns and other weapons = close enough)

Best RPG of the Year: Costume Quest

Best Puzzle game of the Year: Limbo

Best Adventure game of the Year: 999

Best Indie game of the Year: Super Meat Boy

Best Strategy game of the Year: Valkyria Chronicles 2

Best Racing game of the Year: NFS Hot Pursuit

Best Action game of the Year: Bayonetta

Best Platformer of the Year: Super Mario Galaxy 2

Best Fighting game of the Year: Tatsunoko vs Capcom

Best Action Adventure game of the Year: Enslaved Odyssey to the West
 
Best game of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best FPS of the Year: Battle Field Bad Company 2

Best TPS of the Year: Alan Wake

Best RPG of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best Adventure game of the Year: Red Dead Redemption

Best Simulation game of the Year: NBA 2k11

Best Strategy game of the Year: Game Dev Story

Best Indie game of the Year: Minecraft

Best Sports game of the Year: Madden NFL 11
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Best game of the Year: Final Fantasy XIII

Best FPS of the Year: Battlefield Bad Company 2

Best TPS of the Year:

Best RPG of the Year: Final Fantasy XIII

Best Puzzle game of the Year:

Best Adventure game of the Year: Heavy Rain

Best Simulation game of the Year: Gran Turismo 5

Best Strategy game of the Year: Starcraft II

Best Indie game of the Year: Super Meat Boy

Best MMO of the Year: WoW Cataclysm

Best Racing game of the Year: Gran Turismo 5

Best Sports game of the Year:

Best Platformer game of the Year:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I won't even bother pretending that I played all the heavy hitters out, whether that's due to being a cheap ass gamer, the games just weren't aligned to my tastes, or a mix of the two.


Best game of the Year: Super Mario Galaxy 2 (Mario is on a roll, and I gotta give props) 10/10

Best Platformer: Super Mario Galaxy 2 (Donkey Kong Country Returns was good, but it's difficult to take on a platforming giant such as Mario. Additionally, haven't gotten around to Super Meat Boy or Kirby, but I highly doubt they outclass the likes of Mario.) 10/10

Best RPG of the Year: Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story (I'm a sucker for cute mario rpgs, but had I played Costume Quest, Fallout Vegas, or FFXIII, I might have just altered this selection.) 7/10

Best Puzzle and Action/Adventure game of the Year: Lara Croft and the Guardian of Light (I wouldn't mind the next Tomb Raider borrowing some of these concepts, specifically in its execution of co-op) 9/10

Best Shooter: Vanquish (Although, it didn't innovate the shooter genre as much as I had hoped) (I really haven't played any other shooters this year, so I only put down the only one I've gotten around to playing.) 7/10

Best Adventure game of the Year: 999. (I was tempted to say Last Window, but the story is much more gripping and the puzzles are more intelligent, even if parts of the dialogue and characterization can be dry at times.) 8/10

Best Racing game of the Year: Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing (Although, I prefer the chaos of Mario Kart. It's an okay game I suppose.) 6/10

Biggest Disappointments:

Enslaved (Again, a sad case of game trying to be a movie. Everything in this feels too automatic)
Castlevania Lords of Shadow (You've played this game before, and it was done better at that)
Heavy Rain (Boring story and limited gameplay does not a game make)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Best Platformer: Donkey Kong Country Returns

Best Racing game of the Year: Sonic and Sega All Stars Racing

Best Sports game of the Year: NBA Jam

Best Fighter of the Year: Super Street Fighter IV

Best FPS: Halo Reach

Best Action Game: God Of War III

I really don't know what to choose for game of the year. Last year it was much easier.
 
Best game of the Year: Enslaved

Best FPS of the Year: Battlefield Bad Company 2

Best TPS of the Year: Uncharted 2 GOTY

Best Action/Adventure game of the Year: Enslaved

Best Strategy game of the Year: Starcraft 2

Best Indie game of the Year: Super Meat Boy

Best MMO of the Year: WoW: Cataclysm

Best Racing game of the Year: Gran Turismo 5

Best Sports game of the Year: MLB 10
 
In my sig. :)

Best add-on:

Mass Effect 2: Liar of The Shadow Broker.
944907_99727.jpg


Runners Up: Red Dead Redemption: Undead Nightmare, Dragon Age Origins: Awakening


Best Arcade Title:

Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World
961765_127926.jpg


Runners Up: Limbo, Risk Factions


Best Shooter:

Red Dead Redemption
957922_119989.jpg


Runners Up: Battlefield Bad Company 2, Bioshock 2


Best RPG:

Mass Effect 2
944907_99727.jpg


Runners Up: Atellier Rorona: Alchemist of Arland, Fallout New Vegas



Best Action Adventure Game

Bayonetta
946346_102471.jpg


Runners Up: God of War 3, Assassins Creed Brotherhood




Best Adventure:

Heavy Rain
933123_154032.jpg


Runners Up: Spider Man: Shattered Deminsion


Best Fighting:

BlazBlue Continuum Shift
blazblue_continuum_shift_frontcover_small_yMyqaKZKtW2Kktw.jpg


Runners up: Naruto Shippuden Ultimate Ninja Storm 2, Super Street Fighter IV


Best Original Title

Alan Wake
928006_66985.jpg


Runners Up: Heavy Rain, Bayonetta, Vanquish.



Best Multiplayer:

Battlefield Bad Company 2
957916_119983.jpg


Runners Up: Call of Duty Black Ops, Halo Reach


Game of They Year

Mass Effect 2
944907_99727.jpg


Runners Up: Battlefield Bad Company 2, Red Dead Redemption, Bayonetta.
 
Best game of the Year: Just Cause 2
Best FPS of the Year: Battlefield: Bad Company 2
Best TPS of the Year: Monday Night Combat
Best RPG of the Year: Persona 3 Portable
Best Puzzle game of the Year: Picross 3D
Best Adventure game of the Year: Heavy Rain
Best Strategy game of the Year: Valkyria Chronicles 2
Best Indie game of the Year: Joe Danger
Best Racing game of the Year: Need for Speed: Hot Pursuit
Best Sports game of the Year: MLB 10: The Show
Best Action Game of the Year: God of War III
Best Music Game of the Year: Rock Band 3
Best Platformer of the Year: Kirby's Epic Yarn
Best Open World Game of the Year: Just Cause 2
Best Shooter of the Year: Space Invaders: Infinity Gene (XBLA/PSN)

Added some categories that the OP ignored.
 
Haven't played Mass Effect 2, Darksiders, Alan Wake, Splinter Cell, Reach,Limbo,Fallout New Vegas, Heavy Rain,Yakuza 3, or Just Cause 2 yet.


Game of the Year: Red Dead Redemption (runners up:AC: Brotherhood, Bayonetta)
Downloadable GOTY: Super Meat Boy (Runner Up: Dead Rising Case Zero)
 
On my site GamerFill.com, I run down my personal top 20 games of 2010 which you can read here :
http://www.gamerfill.com/content.php?217-Brandon-s-Top-20-Games-of-2010

I would still like to share my picks in this thread, so here it goes...

Best game of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best FPS of the Year: COD BLOPS

Best TPS of the Year: Red Dead

Best RPG of the Year: FF XIII

Best Puzzle game of the Year: PB Winterbottom

Best Adventure game of the Year: Sam and Max: Devils Playground

Best Simulation game of the Year: Gran Turismo 5

Best Strategy game of the Year: Didn't play any "good" strategy games this year.

Best Indie game of the Year: Limbo

Best MMO of the Year: No clue.

Best Racing game of the Year: Need For Speed HP

Best Sports game of the Year: Madden 11
 
[quote name='JasonTerminator']I'm sure Machinarium is a good game, but it came out LAST year, so please stop nominating it.[/QUOTE]
I blame Giant Bomb
 
Of all the games that came out in 2010, I've only played Dante's Inferno and Alpha Protocol.

I really don't get why AP was trashed so heavily. It's almost like the people reviewing the game didn't know what kind of game it was.
 
[quote name='wwe101']you all don't know what your missing:)[/QUOTE]

A lot of people think Deadly Premonition is a bad game, but that's usually because they haven't played it (or haven't played much of it).

It's not really "so bad that it's good." It's more along the lines of "so weird that it's good." And in many ways it is just plain good.

It's not for everyone though, and anyone who is a fan of Twin Peaks will probably get a bit more out of it, but I think that everyone should at least give it a chance before assuming that someone isn't serious when calling it GOTY.
 
I know it's mainstream (and I hate going mainstream) but I had a so much fun with Mass Effect 2 that it wins the spot for me. One of the few games this year truly worth a $60 price tag.

Why does Castlevania get so much hate? I see it on everyone's disappointed list. When you get down to it, it's at least a good game. FFXIII is not only a disappointment but a terrible game. I've heard people say, "At least the story is good" but I don't see it.
 
I was disappointed in it but I thought it was a decent game. Same with FF13, I was thoroughly disappointed in it moreso then any other game this year, but it was decent.
 
Best game of the Year: Final Fantasy XIII

Best FPS of the Year: Halo: Reach & Battlefield Bad Company 2

Best TPS of the Year: Mass Effect 2

Best RPG of the Year: Final Fantasy XIII

Best Indie game of the Year: West

Best Racing game of the Year: Hydro Thunder Hurricane

Best Sports game of the Year: NBA 2K11

Best XBLA/PSN game: The Secret of Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge Special Edition

Best letdown: Red Dead Redemption

Best game(s) that came out years ago that you played in 2010: Tales of Vesperia & Lost Odyssey
 
Last edited by a moderator:
[quote name='Rodimus']
Why does Castlevania get so much hate? I see it on everyone's disappointed list. When you get down to it, it's at least a good game.[/QUOTE]

Well the thing is, I didn't think Castlevania was even a good game. It had high production values, a lot of content, and was very polished, but I thought everything else was bad. Cheap repetitive enemies that took too many hits to kill, terribly boring climbing sections, far too much narration (that isn't in any way reflected by the game), dumb story that takes itself too seriously (the epilogue was cool though), unfun SOTC style boss fights, cliche puzzles that weren't fun or clever, pointless chupacabra sections, and a bunch of smaller issues as well. But that's just me of course.
 
[quote name='Cheddahz']Best arcade game: The Secret of Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge Special Edition[/QUOTE]

So, does the arcade version cost a quarter every time you change screens or what?

Seems like an odd choice for an arcade game, seeing as you can't die and all. I'll have to go to my local arcade to check that shit out!
 
bread's done
Back
Top