For anyone interested, I have played the first few chapters of the new game (playing on PC). The graphics are pretty good, but nothing great. (sadly only 3 options: V-sync, and level of shadows, and textures) I am played maxed with a GTX660Ti in 1080p and have not anywhere near a hint of trouble. I suspect a 460 or 560 could max this game without ANY issue.
Gameplay is very smooth and fluid, and the overall level design in very cinematic. There will be several times you just want to look around, even though the graphics aren't as good as say, Battlefield 3, its still colorful and vivid and looks nice. Everyone expect Kirk(? I know, right?) character models are very accurate.
Enterpirse bridge looks pretty good, but a few of the bridge console screens have little detail. I think making those crystal clear would have really added some authenticity to the atmosphere.
The writing and voice acting is great, They make great use of the original cast and writers, and the Spock/Kirk is quite humorous at times.
I'm playing on easy on my first run just to enjoy it, and that may be the problem, but the AI is stupid. enemies just act at like mindless animals that dont realize you can kill them, and oddly, even when in "cover" they stick out since the gorn are so big.
The space battles are decent. They aren't bad, but doesn't add to the game IMO.
The Spock/Kirk interactions and jokes and the solid (but unrevolutionary) gameplay are what sell me on it. Spock's witty remarks to Kirks exploits are pure Trek. Expect a fun romp in the world of Trek, but don't expect a revolutionary game.
I have NOT played in co op yet but I suspect that will help with some friendly AI issues(its not BAD, but its not particularly good either, they don't help you too much, but don't get in your way or slow you down either)
In single player, at least the game is very manageable without another human. it's possible they dumb the enemy ai down to help with this, which would explain the enemy AI.
One odd thing to me is the cinematic sequences. One near the game start is kinda pixelated, while one in chapter 3 looks really good, they are just CGI video sequences
Overall, I am pleased with my purchase($37.50).