Top Spin Tennis 4

texasnightowl

CAGiversary!
Here's the review I just left on Amazon about this offering:

Needs a happy medium

Note 1: This review does not include Move functionality...played using standard SixAxis controller.

Note 2: Primary play type was Career mode.

Normal difficulty is too easy and Hard is too hard.

I played for several hours yesterday and that is my conclusion. I started with the normal (default) difficulty. I created a female character to play career mode. I played 6 tournaments and each tourney consists of 3 possible "matches". So that is 18 "matches" I played and won all of them very easily. So then I switched to "Hard" difficulty and proceeded to lose the next 8 matches I played. So in Normal mode I easily defeated players at higher "levels" than my player (ie. while I was a level "4" I was beating level "10" and "12" players) and then on Hard difficulty, I was losing badly to players at lower levels (ie. I was up to a level "12" and was losing to level "4" players).

So, personally, I believe the AI is really screwy when it comes to difficulty.

On other notes, the constant saving is tiresome and slow. Even with autosave supposedly turned off it saves *all* the time. Especially in the Player Evolution/My Player areas. And load times also seem extended.

It is also a bit frustrating that you are only allowed 1 "preparation" event and 1 "tournament" per month. Some of the preparation events are 2 weeks of yoga or attending a club opening! (though there are practice/sparring matches also available). I'd rather have had the option of 2 events per month total...up to the player whether to play a practice event or not (I did not) or play 2 tournaments per month.

Actual play is decent with respect to button usage to hit the ball and type of shots. But sometimes it feels like it is unresponsive in terms of movement - in particular after hitting a ball and trying to recover to center of court - it just sometimes seems like it is ignoring your input to move.

I also played one "Exhibition" mode match. I played as Agassi with the AI as Becker. I won easily...but the AI as Becker only approached the net once. Yes, Becker had some respectable groundstrokes...but to only approach the net *ONCE* in a match? No. Just no.

So to sum up...I find this a flawed game. Yes, decent playability re: strokes, especially as compared to TS3, but this is definitely flawed. Of TS4, TS3, or VT3, my favorite to date is VT3. I'm anxious to see how the new VT turns out.
 
Nice review - it sums up my experience with the demo. It felt so clunky and unresponsive - i wonder if it works well with the Move. On the demo, i experienced the same thing you did as it regards the difficulty setting and it's a shame that the full game did nothing to rectify this problem. Here's hoping VT4 turns out a lot better.
 
Thanks. I'm now completely convinced that the AI is flawed. I continued playing career mode on the "normal" level and reached the point where I'm allowed to enter the Grand Slam events. Everything is fine thru the 1st, 2nd, and Quarterfinals...I win convincingly as usual. Then the Semi final arrives and the AI player is on a completely different level. And I do mean completely. Example...during the "Wimbledon" aka Dublin Open Quarterfinal I played Serena Williams and waxed her. Then in the SF I played Wozniacki and couldn't win a game. On to the US Open I waxed Jankovic and got Serena for the SF. Whereas I had defeated Serena easily in the Wimbledon QF the AI was so completely overwhelming I was lucky to get 1 pt per game! Completely frustrating. I wouldn't mind if the AI player were better as long as it wasn't such a HUGE jump going from QF to SF. It is really quite ridiculous.

I think I'll be seeing what GameStop will give me in trade value for this game.
 
[quote name='texasnightowl']Thanks. I'm now completely convinced that the AI is flawed. I continued playing career mode on the "normal" level and reached the point where I'm allowed to enter the Grand Slam events. Everything is fine thru the 1st, 2nd, and Quarterfinals...I win convincingly as usual. Then the Semi final arrives and the AI player is on a completely different level. And I do mean completely. Example...during the "Wimbledon" aka Dublin Open Quarterfinal I played Serena Williams and waxed her. Then in the SF I played Wozniacki and couldn't win a game. On to the US Open I waxed Jankovic and got Serena for the SF. Whereas I had defeated Serena easily in the Wimbledon QF the AI was so completely overwhelming I was lucky to get 1 pt per game! Completely frustrating. I wouldn't mind if the AI player were better as long as it wasn't such a HUGE jump going from QF to SF. It is really quite ridiculous.

I think I'll be seeing what GameStop will give me in trade value for this game.[/QUOTE]

Where can I sign up to wax female tennis players?
 
[quote name='texasnightowl']I think I'll be seeing what GameStop will give me in trade value for this game.[/QUOTE]

You'd be better off just listing the game on eBay - try to recoup as much as you possibly can. Or just sell it here, i'm sure they'll be someone looking to buy.
 
Well, Amazon finally posted a trade-in value of $37.50. Considering the $20 credit I got for pre-ordering and the release day price of $56.99, and I'm coming out $0.51 ahead. I'm OK with coming out even.
 
bread's done
Back
Top