[quote name='Vinny']I understand that but it's not like they're buying the Japanese ones, whiting out the text and writing over them with English. They'll be printing the books themselves, meaning they'll also handle the actual design (or.. translation)... so why not just combine the two into one massive, hardcover book? You know it'll sell either way but the games have been out for so long that I just can't see the need for having two separate books.[/QUOTE]
I'd rather they have separate books. It is much more aesthetically pleasing to me, and that's basically what this argument is all about. Besides, there wouldn't be consistent sizing when the massive Persona book stands next to the Shigenori Soejima book that they're also releasing, which heavily relates to the topic at hand since he was the art designer for both P3 and 4. A bigger book is also more susceptible to spinal damage of its binding (if it's softcover).