Dyansty Warriors series- always gets rated low in game mags and websites
Rocky Legends- I finished all career modes in one day, playing from about 9AM to midnight.
Time Killers- Loved the arcade game, heard the Genesis port blew big time. I got good enough at the arcade I could beat the game on one credit.
Battle Monsters- Old Saturn game, and I have to admit, it looks terrible. It's so bad, it's good. To me leastways.
Supreme Warrior- Sega CD/32X combo game. First-person fighting game using FMV. Cheesy as all hell, but damn I loved every minute. "PREPARE FOR DEATH!"
Master of Orion 3- PC game that got a smattering of good reviews, but most bashed it. Lot of MOO fans hated it, I played one game of MOO3 over 8 months, as in I would play a few turns a night over that period of time. Forgot to back up my game save during a reformat...
Battle Arena Toshinden- The first PSX game I ever bought, at the same time I bought my first PSX. Everyone looks at Tekken now and thinks BAT blows. I thought it was great, though I will say that BAT2 was the first time my disappointment with a game was palpable.
King's Field series- I could never understand the hating on this series. First person action-RPG? Yes, please.
I will also admit to liking True Crime, both Raw wrestling games on Xbox, and both Red Faction games.