Which do you prefer: X-Play or Judgement Day

[XboxMaster]

Which do you prefer? IMO, I think Judgement Day is the better show. Now that I have a choice of review shows, I definitely think Judgement Day is better. Mostly because they fit a lot more material in one show. They usually review I think three next-gen games, one GBA game, an accessory, and they do a Hidden Treasure. While X-Play only covers three to four next-gen or GBA games. I also like the reviews done by JD over X-Play. I think X-Play is usually over-critical, although I will admit that Tommy on JD is usually negative about most games they review.

 

[RedvsBlue]

The one thing I don't like about Judgement Day is Tommy Tallarico, oh yeah also the fact that they treat the audience like we are all children.

 

[fifthcore]

[quote name='RedvsBlue']The one thing I don't like about Judgement Day is Tommy Tallarico, oh yeah also the fact that they treat the audience like we are all children.[/quote]

Same here I hate Tommy Tallarico he makes the show so crappy.

 

[XboxMaster]

[quote name='fifthcore'][quote name='RedvsBlue']The one thing I don't like about Judgement Day is Tommy Tallarico, oh yeah also the fact that they treat the audience like we are all children.[/quote]

Same here I hate Tommy Tallarico he makes the show so crappy.[/quote]


I just think he's a little too negative about most games. But he does provide laughs at times.

 

[xzafixz]

Neither, both of those shows make me ashamed to be a gamer.

 

[sblymnlcrymnl]

X Play is at least entertaining, Judgement day is just awful.

 

[pimp_daddy_smurf]

the only reason for xplay is morgan webb. seriously, i know enough about games that i dont need to watch a show on it, thats what the internet is for.

MWL returns!!!!!

 

[Kaijufan]

Tommy needs to be fired. He should be blacklisted by the videogame review industry. He brings the whole show down, and makes X Play look even better.

 

[Murcielago77]

xplay is better than judgement day. Tommy tallarico sucks and the episodes are like 90% reruns. Hey sblymnlcrymnl the avatar and sig are hot

 

[dnt_h8me2]

Both shows are terrible, but I choose X-Play because
Morgan makes it tolerable. Adam & Tommy should both be shot IMO.

 

[LinkinPrime]

I like the one with the 2 chicks and the guy, G4TV.

 

[dnt_h8me2]

[quote name='LinkinPrime']I like the one with the 2 chicks and the guy, G4TV.[/quote]

I think they fired the guy that was on there, but I could be wrong.
And I think that new guy on Screen Savers if ing annoying.

 

[dnt_h8me2]

[quote name='LinkinPrime']I like the one with the 2 chicks and the guy, G4TV.[/quote]

I think they fired the guy that was on there, but I could be wrong.
And I think that new guy on Screen Savers if ing annoying.

 

[metaphysix]

Tommy Tallarico is great. I like dumb smartass-ness added to my gamer information, so Judgement Day is up my alley. I've watched alot of X-Play lately, and don't like how most games (not all) get a 4/5. However, in X-Plays defense... both hosts act like they're really into a game they give a good rating too. And they do have Morgan Webb. While not affecting my views on games... it's gotta count for something lol.

 

[SadieDee]

I definately prefer X-Play over Judgement Day. I like Adam and Morgan because they're quirky, but Tommy gets on my nerves most of the time. Sometimes his sarcasm is funny, but most of the time it falls flat or is in bad taste. Victor is okay and balances the show out. I hate it when Tommy is like "I don't like this game because it has Kirby in it." WTF!?? Who shoved the JigglyPuff up his butt?

I don't really like any of the G4 crew. I miss the old TechTV. The TechTV people have personality. You can tell the G4 people are reading a teleprompter. I know they all do, but the G4 crew just...sucks!

I really really really do not like Tina or Laura. I refuse to watch them.

 

[bluenatas09]

God awful waste of air space, both of them.

 

[sblymnlcrymnl]

[quote name='dnt_h8me2'][quote name='LinkinPrime']I like the one with the 2 chicks and the guy, G4TV.[/quote]

I think they fired the guy that was on there, but I could be wrong.
And I think that new guy on Screen Savers if shaq-fuing annoying.[/quote]

I've basically stopped watching TSS since he came on board and they moved to the new studio.

 

[mousin]

judgement day is the stupidest video game shower period. its dumb, i give this a 8.531231 cause it doesnt have this stupid crap. x-play is entertaining, the stuff they got on.. like morgan web? shes hot. and yea .. shes hot.

 

[nickmad]

judgement day is the worst show in television history....

tommy tallarico is a bumbling retard who hates games just because he loves to rag on shit. i hate the good guy and bad guy angle they use to try and review games.

xplay is at least entertaining, adam sessler is a funny bumbling retard and morgan webb is fine as hell.

in general G4TechTV sucks major ass....the screensavers has been turned into a ing idiot circus....Some one at the lame station, grab a coat hangar and yank that shit off the air!!

 

[killswitch64]

[quote name='pimp_daddy_smurf']the only reason for xplay is morgan webb. seriously, i know enough about games that i dont need to watch a show on it, thats what the internet is for.

MWL returns!!!!![/quote]

Right on the $$$!

 

[ZForce915]

When I used to be able to watch X-Play (lousy shift to digital cable), I loved that show. LOVED IT. I'd watch shows with games I knew I'd never play. It was a blast and I miss it.

 

[fireball343]

i can't stand x-play, they mergerd a game network with a tech network(watched and loved both networks) and they keep the tech networks game show. i never really liked x-play that much, they don't score things good at all.

i would like to see a show, like cinematech, but it actually ran trailers and gameplay from up-coming games and that be it, like some trailers for MGS3 and Halo2 and some GTA SA, because i can get text, i can't get a hi-res trailer on my 17inch, compared to my 70inch.