OP: Is that based on a true story?
I got a horror story of a game I lent out. I worked in a video game store when I was younger and a co-worker of mine (I'll call him Rufus) just got a Saturn. Rufus knew I had a nice Saturn collection and asked if he could borrow a game. I said sure and ended up lending him Panzer Dragoon Saga. Rufus was always picked on at school, and had really low self-esteem so I felt sorry for him. He seemed honest enough like a quiet nerd but made him understand how rare this game was and he agreed if anything happened to it he would be responsible for it.
So about a week goes by, Im at work and Rufus comes in through the back door holding a plastic bag, pushing a busted bike, crying and saying his arm was hurt. He claimed he was on his bike headed to work when a car forced him off the road crashing, hurting his arm, bending the wheel on his bike and destroying the game. I looked in the bag and sure enough my Panzer Dragoon Saga was badly damaged. The case was shattered, two disks were cracked in half. I put the game aside to see if Rufus was okay, but he declined going to the hospital, no scrapes or bruises. He apologized for the game, but he was still crying and shaken up so we sent him home saying we can deal with it later.
So Rufus comes back the next day and we discuss what should be done about my very rare Panzer Dragoon Saga. Something felt off about his story, I didn't see any injuries on him, but my game and his bike were trashed. A bunch of different things could've happened. My guess is Rufus got jumped by bullies and they trashed my game (thinking it was his) and his bike. Whatever it was it's obvious he was too embarrassed to tell us the truth. I should've pressed the issue but I didn't. Anyways we settled on $100 for the game and I sold the manual, insert and 2 working disks on ebay and made out about even.
Years later I learn some very odd things about him. He ran off to Vermont with some middle aged hairy dude and was really into gay furry porn. I'm not making this up.