I just bought a HL-2170W last week at Office Depot for $90. More than I wanted to spend but considering I wasn't even getting 500 prints for $50 worth of black ink only with the all in one Lexmark ink jet I had, I figure it'll pay for itself in money saved on ink in less than a year (at least in my case). The printer was $80 on Black Friday and I was still stalling then but finally got fed up with the cost of a single print.
Anyway there was a thread like this not too long ago and most people responded with recommendations to check Target clearance isles for HP printers. That still might be a decent bet if you aren't going to be doing a a lot of printing. Pretty sure HP, Epson, and Lexmark will all bleed your wallet on ink. Part of the problem with ink jet printers, and the alternatives can be expensive. Oh and this time of year Target might be cleaned out on clearance printers so check ads too. I believe Staples is still running a promotion where you can trade in any printer (no matter how old or broken I believe) and get $50 off any HP printer.