[quote name='notfromtexas']You had the same problem with your red controller??[/QUOTE]
I had trouble getting a good charge on my red battery, although at first, it would get at least a partial charge. Tried it in multiple controllers, using two diferent play-and-charge cables. Finally, one time, it just wouldn't charge at all. The light would go immediately to green, indicating it was done charging, but if I unplugged the cable, the controller would die almost instantly. I bought a quick charge instead, and it worked much, much better. Much more consistant. Maybe it's the full AC 120v power as opposed to the low-dose USB trickle charge, but it flat out works better in my experience than the cables.