Fable - Peter Molyneux hyped this up way too much before it was released, so I'm not listening to him about Fable 2 this time around. It's still a good game, but I wanted the hyped version.
VF4: Evolution - Removed my favorite feature from the original (AI) for not much new stuff.
Crazy Taxi 3 - Not bad, but the first two games that are included are hard to perform Crazy moves with the Controller S.
Controller S - I heard nothing but good things about the controller before I got an Xbox, but it's not that good. The triggers are horribly-placed, the black and white buttons are awkwardly-placed, and the d-pad sucks.
Shenmue 2 (DC) - One of my most anticipated DC games cancelled and moved to the Xbox weeks before it was to be released in the US. It kind of just kicked you in the nuts as the DC was winding down.
Kirby (GC) - Even though this hasn't been released yet, that's kind of the reason why it's such a let down. We haven't seen a console Kirby game yet and it'll be a
ing shame if it gets moved to the Wii or just cancelled.
Final Fantasy: CC and Legend of Zelda: Four Swords - The connectivity requirement to play these games in multiplayer extremely limits the potential appeal that these games could've had. Not everyone has three friends with GBA's and the right cable, so it's too expensive of a game for them.