Alice: The Madness Returns - Never played the orginal but this dark creepy Wonderland concept always intrigued me. Amazing environment pieces that just draw you in. Plus Alice has some of the best hair physics in a game ever. I would often just sit around for a few mintues looking at the background.
Captain America: Super Soldier - Every once and a while I'm surprised by a movie tie-in game and last year it was Cap. The developers obviuosly took a cue from Arkham Asylum. My favorite part: Combat never gets boring. And for those achievement hunters it's a fairly easy 1000/1000. Compared to the massive P.O.S. that Thor was Cap was refreshing.
Shadows of the Damned - Three words best descride this game "bat shit crazy." Countless WTF moments in Shadows. Think Resident Evil 4 meets No More Heroes. Besides, what other game has you walking across a nekkid lady's bare ass?
Catherine - Wasn't sure whether to put this on the list or not. I wouldn't recomend Cathrine to just anyone but it sure was a unique experience, good enough for a playthrough. But do you know the difference between Whiskey and Sctoch? Play Cathrine to find out, it's educational.
Edited by Rodimus, 30 January 2012 - 09:54 PM.