[quote name='BigSpoonyBard']Let's be honest; Lebron can't truly be in the conversation for two combined reasons: He wasn't playing until pretty much halfway through the decade, and his first couple seasons teams were more than willing to let him shoot from outside since he couldn't shoot yet. That's a pretty glaring weakness for a dominant player. He's pretty much fixed that issue now, but even if we give him the last three years, that's not enough for the decade's honors.
I think to give someone the call, they'd have to have been at peak abilities for at least seven seasons in the decade. For example, Shaq's abilities were clearly on a decline even during the Miami Heat run. Dwayne Wade won that championship. The last half of the decade for Shaq has been much less than dominant, so I would have a hard time giving it to him.
With that said, I think my list would come down to a handful of players who had a complete package of offense and defense for the majority of the decade:
- Tim Duncan
- Kobe Bryant
- Kevin Garnett
Dirk struggled with spelling, let alone playing, defense for quite a few years, so I can't see him in the list. Nash would give up 50 points to most high school j.v. players, so he's out. As much as I love Jason Kidd, I think most teams would have willingly let him try to shoot his teams to wins for most of the decade (where the hell did his three-point shooting this season come from?).[/QUOTE]
Kidd has always been a solid spot up three point shooter; it wasn't until he was traded back to Dallas that he was able to play off the ball and take more of his favored shots. Had he done this for half a season I'd write it off as small sample size, but he's been well over 40% for 200 games now.
Kobe's defense has been vastly overrated for nearly his entire career; in his first three post-Shaq seasons he was actually below league average in DRtg. He was so bad in 04-05 that he tied Steve f'n Nash with a 111 mark. When Bynum emerged, and the Lakers traded for Gasol, his DRtg returned to slightly above league average. His defensive reputation is based off his 1999-2000 season, which was objectively awesome in its ballhawking greatness.
Dirk's first five seasons of the 2000s, steals | blocks | DRtg (league average tends to fall between 106 and 107):
2000-01: 1.0, 1.2, 100
2001-02: 1.1, 1.0, 104
2002-03: 1.4, 1.0, 98
2003-04: 1.2, 1.4, 104
2004-05: 1.2, 1.5, 100
Dude's played defense for a long time. His awkward stride and lack of lateral quickness makes him look like a poor defender; he's the anti-Kobe in this regard.
With all that said, here's my personal top 5 for the 2000s:
1. Tim Duncan
2. Kevin Garnett - last two years have lessened his hold on this spot
3. Dirk Nowitzki
4. Kobe Bryant - as much as I rip on the guy, he's been a top 15 player - oftentimes more elite - every year of the decade, sans 04-05
5. Shaq - as much as I'd like to put LeBron in this spot, as Shaq's lows from this decade are more elongated and pronounced than James', dude was a force for the first six seasons of the decade. Plus he has four titles. Had LeBron's career started one year earlier I would have put him here without thinking twice.
Just missed the cut:
LeBron (any player who puts up two consecutive seasons that rival peak Jordan and a postseason that are peerless belongs in an all-decade discussion), Pau Gasol, Steve Nash, Jason Kidd, Paul Pierce
If I were to think further about this I'd come up with a more comprehensive missed cut list, and better analysis for my selections.