Just got a new sealed copy at my local gamestop, at first the clerk put my membership number and then she scanned the game, and it automatically took the $10 off, but whe she tried to finish the transaction it went up to $19.99, she tried a few times and it kept doing the samething, she then said the offer is for pro members, I had the pro but it is now expired, I told her that I saw the offer is good for both free and pro memberships, she then scanned the game and put on my membership # and it worked, so just make sure they scan the game before they scan your card, just a heads up in case they insist that the offer is only for pro members only, which is a complete lie,