[quote name='Strell']I'll throw in my "PRZ DONT RUSE ICE CUH-RYYM-BAHS" vote.[/quote]
I'm going to blow my cover on this one, but the match you speak of happened on the good old BATTLEFIELD stage. Donny's consumption of Ice Climbers' power had personified by the satisfied yell "KIRBY UNDERCOVER, BITCH!" and complete mayhem, since I don't think that any of us had any idea who was who, INCLUDING Donny after he went "undercover."
You actually paused the game to cry from laughter, Strell, which pissed me off quite a bit, as I recall, being that I really wanted to pwn Kirby bad. You actually put your controller down, and wiped the tears out of your eyes. That was, arguably, one of the best Smash Bros. matches ever played.
Although... My best experience was when I was getting my ass beat in a Mario vs. Mario battle on Majora Mask stage. My buddy sealed the deal, and I was doing down into the ocean. I must have tried to recover something like seven times in a row, while being constantly knocked out in the area where the turtle used to be. Finally, he slammed me down, and I gave up.
The waters moved, and my Mario emerged, looking strikingly victorious, above the turtle, whose decision to surface could not have possibly come at a better time. We were both so awestruck at the impeccable timing and dramatic effect, that we hesitated a second or two, before I inevitably jumped of the turtle and smashed the
out of Brandon.
I can not think of a single other game that I've gotten such mileage out of. That considered, bring it on with new characters, and bring it on without Ice Climbers: as long as Wii takes the GCN disks, I would love a reason to put the Melee disk back in.
EDIT: Removed pretentious language.