Yeah, I mean I think at worst there's INSANE production values and something there for almost anyone who likes interactive entertainment. I think I'm somewhere in the middle with it. I'm not super crazy about the gameplay, but I enjoyed it, ditto for the story. I think there's all kinds of depth to the gameplay that I skipped-I set it to easy, as I don't want to have to master the finer points of it-lets you play it really differently.
But anyway, at worst it's incredibly well produced and usually fun, even if you're just blazing through it. I kept my copy, which is more than I can say for most games (including MGS3). I even don't mind Snake on my system's box (and wouldn't mind if he was on my system too).