I stopped in at Target yesterday and according to them, the same games that qualify on the website aren't the same ones that qualify in store. There was no "Buy 2, get $20 off" sign on several games, such as Dream Trigger, Street Fighter, Steel Diver, and Super Monkey Ball.
I asked the sales associate if those games qualified and she said no. I pointed out that they were on the website, so she scanned several of them. According to her, she said that the deal showed up on the titles with signs that she scanned, but not the ones without signs (the four I listed above).
Anyone had any luck with those four games in store?