[quote name='msu89dawgs']I just cancelled my Amazon pre-order of the 360 HD DVD drive, and ordered a Toshiba HD-A1 plus Batman Begins, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and Corpse Bride. I'm going to send in the Toshiba 3 free HD DVD movies coupon, and get Apollo 13, Constantine, and We Were Soldiers. That's a touch under $450 for the player and six movies, with standard shipping included. Figuring in the movies at $20 each in value, that comes to right at $330 for the player, which is a fair price to me for the new technology. I paid $500 for my first DVD player, and was very happy with the purchase.
Here are my two main reasons for the change of heart:
1. I can hook up the HD-A1 through the HDMI to my HDTV, and get upconversion of standard DVDs to "near-HD". From what I've read, the Toshiba HD DVD players do an excellent job of upconversion of standard DVDs. Also, by using HDMI, should HD DVDs ever begin to implement ICT, it won't be an issue to me. With the 360 player, I can't get upconversion of standard DVDs that I'm aware of. I know I don't get 1080p with the HD-A1, which isn't an issue to me, since my TV only does 1080i, and I'll have it for the next several years. By the time I get ready for a new TV, which will do 1080p, either HD DVD will have gained more market penetration, and newer HD DVD players capable of 1080p HDMI output will be available at a lower price point, or HD DVD will have flopped, in which case I'll have moved to Blu-Ray or whatever HD movie format is around (assuming any of them can gain a hold in the market).
2. With the 2.0 firmware update for the HD-A1, Dolby TrueHD can now be output in 5.1 from the analog audio outputs on the player. I know Batman Begins has a TrueHD 5.1 track, and I'm sure more movies are to come. I also get Dolby Digital Plus and DTS-HD through the analog outs. I have invested a lot in my receiver and speakers, and I want to be able to get the best quality audio from HD movies. It's worth the extra cost of the HD-A1 to get the higher resolution audio tracks. With the 360 player, my only audio output option is the fiber optic output, and the new audio formats will be downmixed to DTS, from what I understand. I don't see Microsoft ever releasing a multichannel audio AV adapter for the 360 to allow the less lossy/uncompressed audio to be sent to my receiver, as I doubt the demand will be there.
In short, the 360 HD DVD drive is crippled when it comes to delivering the full HD DVD experience, especially in the audio department, to the point where it's worth it to me to pay the extra to get the better feature set that the HD-A1 offers. I think there's definitely a place for the 360 HD DVD drive at its price point vs. current standalone players, especially for those who use the 360 as their DVD player as well, and who might not either have the HT audio equipment to get the higher quality audio from HD movies, or for whom it might not be a priority, and just want the better picture quality of HD DVDs.[/quote]
You know i just don't get why people are so excited about adding another dvd drive to their 360, because the hd player is an addon, why not just go buy a standalone hd player, that could be located anywhere and not just attached to the 360, I really think msoft screwed up on this one by not making the dvd player in the 360 replacable with the hd drive, at least in that configuration you could avoid all the extra equipment that the addon box requires.