I stopped at BB while I was out today with success.
I (being 19) waited so that could go to the young female cashier. Acting super kind and a bit flirty I had her going not really thinking. She took the price off the two games and said it was not working. She said let me get my manager to confirm. The manager came and was like, we don't pricematch giftcards, what are you doing?
I then politely pulled out a print out of their policy and was like, I printed this off of your website, and came across this. She looked down at it and didnt even look at me and was just like... (to the cashier) go call TRU and see if they have them in stock.
She then told me that she would take $10 off of each game. I pointed her towards the $40 promotion and she insisted that because it was Rewards that they could not do that. I insisted that they could and that it was free just as their Reward Zone program. The lady continued to explain to me, that the Toys R Us Rewards is not the same card as the Reward Zone ones.... as if I did not know. Going into detail how I am unable to take the Reward Zone card to TRU, I continued to stay calm and just asked her politely to just give it to me. After a while she said she would go speak with her boss then. She came back about 3 minutes later and told me that he said that I could do it this one time, but I am not supposed to.
After another few minutes the original girl came back and confirmed the stock at TRU. The one manager took off the price, cutting it to $39.99 each and then left. Apologizing for the inconvenience, I asked if I could try and use a coupon. She of course said okay (it was the Reward Zone 10% coupon) but we had no luck. It registered as the coupon, but it took nothing off most likely due to the drop of price.
Either way, I had a $60 GC already for BB so after quite a hassle, I walked out with both Bayonetta and Darksiders, spending only ~$25 out of pocket. Not bad seeing as I planned on paying full price for Bayonetta. $20 for Darksiders is not half bad!
I hope other people can get it to work with less hassle than most of us have been having!