If I had a Kmart anywhere near me that would definitely be my choice, but reddjoey has consistently remained a hard worker on his thread and done his best to keep CAGs on track.
If I had a Kmart to go to I would vote Josh since I would have been all up in that thread but I have to go with Tony. Those were some great deals from Amazon and the $5 coupons made them a steal especially since some turned out free.
This is probably the toughest award. I regularly post/lurk the majority of these threads and all of these guys are deserving of it. In the end, I voted for reddJoey.