Wow, I don't get to say this hardly ever, but Gaestop really came through for me this time. Not only did they have my sealed copy waiting for me with no hassle, and din't try to charge me over $20 for it, they even had a bin of B1G1 used games at the front, and only 90% of them were shovelware crap. I snagged Uncharted 3 and Modern Warfare 3 used for $7.50 each. Considering that I doubt I'd ever invest enough time in Uncharted 3's multiplayer to make it past the free demo on PSN, and if I did I could just go back to Uncharted 2, I think I came out really well (unless someone can prove otherwise?).
But man these games cleared out quick. Pandora's Tower is now OoS at ALL my local Gamestops, and we have at least one every few miles. I asked, and sure enough, some jackass went to my local store and bought every damn new copy they had except the ones that were opened. Safe to assume that's what happened at the other Gamestops in my town. Thank god I reserved it when I did. And thanks El Hoardo, you nearly cost me another great game __I__.