[quote name='RollingSkull']
All I'm saying is I played it all the way through and hated it, and all my friends, all of them beat it and they ranged from calling it tepid to hating it more than me.[/QUOTE]
Well, "all my friends" bought 10 copies and loved it so much they sleep with them at night. And my beautiful girlfriend, who is from Canada, also loves it, and she never plays games at all.
Seriously?
I can maybe believe you put in the time and trouble to complete the game despite disliking so much. But now "all your friends" bought it (a game few people even heard of), played it, FINISHED it, and disliked/hated it?
Riiiiight. Sounds like you are making %$&# up so you can find more fictional support against this "cult".
Let's just stick to the facts:
* most CAGs not only liked it, but loved it
* most game reviewers loved it (metascore 89)
* Gamespot named it GOTY 2009
* a handful of CAGs found it average or disliked it
And no, I'm not a fanboi or a cultist. I just view "all my friends hated it" comments with great suspicion when the majority liked something. I don't think second-hand stuff like that adds to a productive conversation.