while in general i agree with your statement, in this case i find the reviewer at fault, not the game. he describes the gameplay as,
"El Shaddai is a button-masher, and while you could certainly utilize some cursory combos and skills at your leisure, why would you if the game never really forces you to? You could just mash Square over and over again while occasionally blocking an enemy attack or parrying out of the way of danger."
This is totally wrong as the combat (which only uses one button) is based on timing, thus sometimes waiting to strike/counter attack patiently is more advantageous than a multi hit/button mashing combo. each enemy requires a different approach to combat and while its not the most advanced combat system ever, it is much more complex than the reviewer makes it seem.
In this case the reviewer's ignorance and impatience/lack of strategy are what justify his rating, not the actual game itself.
[quote name='whoknows']As long as they give justification for their score in the review, I don't have a problem with it.
A review is an opinion, and in the IGN reviewers opinion it's not a very good game.[/QUOTE]