Posted this at GameFAQs, may as well post it here. Q: Is EO2 better than EO1?
This game is better in every way but two:
1. MP3 playback support. (Not really missed, it was limited anyway)
2. The overall goal and feel of the game.
What do I mean in number 2?
* As Phisheep said, it seems in this game the animals are there more for scenery than as the object of the game. The plot in the first follows wildlife, especially whales. Almost the entire plot of the second follows a treasure hunting / ancient ruins feel.
* The story is much more gripping as a result. I was blowing through the plot in the second just because of how intrigued I was. I keep telling myself not to do that in games like these, but it always happens.
* The second has more to do, but the first is more relaxing. The second is like school! Four teachers with new assignments every day. Every assignment has a due date, and you have to account for the travel time to and from other locations. I miss the email system from the first game. Nineball Island is almost a waste - the boat hub location in the first was much easier to navigate and get things done.
* Also like Phisheep says, if the first had the graphics of the second, I might even say the first is better or a tie. The first one does almost dump you in the middle of nowhere after the story. At least the second keeps you going after the "end".