[quote name='Daveman'][quote name='guessed'][quote name='Daveman']Quick question for those who have taken part in this (I just took the ad and PM'd at a Best Buy)
Inside the bundle box I can see that the GBA is apparently in it's own box, no different than any other GBA. Is the E-reader in it's own self-contained packaging as well?
If I can return both individually for store credit somewhere... that'd cover the price of a GBA-SP right there.[/quote]
...And would be highly unethical.[/quote]
"Highly?" Maybe... but much more so than asking for rainchecks for games you have no interest in? Buying clearance games from one store and trading them in to another as part of some "trade 4 get 1 free!" deal?
Easy to see I'm new here... my apologies if I've crossed the line.[/quote]
Returning to store A an item which one purchased at store B, as if it had been purchased at store A in the first place is unethical.
Trading games in at store X that were purchased at store Y, is not unethical, at least not with regards to store X (some people argue that it is unethical because it robs other gamers of the opportunity to buy the game at the very cheap price, but that is another issue).
Store X is in the business of buying/trading used games, store A is not. Store A takes the game and gives credit based on the assumption that the game was purchased at store A, and the receipt was lost. Their policy of not requiring a receipt should not be confused with an attitude that they willingly "take back" items, regardless of the store at which they were purchased.
The Target deal is questionable, I can see both sides of it, but I did it, and I am not ashamed. Yes, one could argue that if one has no intention of buying an item, it is unethical to obtain a raincheck for that item. A raincheck, however, is not a commitment to buy, nor is it even an indication of a desire to buy, it is merely a certificate granting the ability to buy, and while it traditionally applies only to a certain item, Target's rainchecks grant an additional ability. It is their policy, it is, perhaps, overly generous, and it will probably change at some point in the not too distant future.
I'm not familiar with the arguments against the GGC coupon.