[quote name='maigoyume']These are my top picks, most have already been mentioned
Animal Crossing (infinite replay value, the game is like sims on crack)
Baten Kaitos (beautiful RPG card based battle system, love it or hate it)
Bomberman Generation (4 player madness, the single player is at least somewhat decent)
Donkey Kong Jungle Beat (underappreciated platformer that uses the bongo peripheral, excellent graphics and gamplay)
Donkey Konga 3 (only if you're willing to import and enjoyed the previous 2, DDR with drums if you will)
Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem (this game will make you think you're crazy, seriously)
F-Zero GX (best racer i've EVER played, difficulty is pretty high though)
Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance (one of the best games to ever grace the little cube, SRPG, if you enjoyed previous iterations of the FE franchise buy this NOW)
Harvest Moon: Magical Melody (best HM since 64, must have if you're a HM fan)
Ikaruga (shoot'em up, brutally hard, but if you have a buddy who will sit with you on this you should be okay)
Legend of Zelda: Collector's Edition (need i say more?)
Legend of Zelda: Four Swords Adventure (the single player is pretty good, i hear its madness with 4 though)
Legend of Zelda: Windwaker (best graphics i've ever seen, its like playing a cel shaded cartoon, briliiant art direction and gameplay is top notch)
Luigi's Mansion (i thoroughly enjoyed the game, but thats up to you)
Lost Kingdoms 2 (best card based rpg i've played to date, give it a shot if you can find it)
Megaman Anniversary and X Collection (nostalgia)
Metroid Prime (faithful recreation of the metroid feel and the game that brought me into the metroid franchise)
Metroid Prime 2 Echoes (not quite as good as prime, but it holds its own with new abilities and returning ones)
Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door (pseudo-rpg, great localization, gameplay is top notch)
Pikmin 1+2 (hard to describe)
Prince of Persia: Sands of Time (platformer, you either love or hate it)
Prince of Persia: Warrior Within (ditto., though it took me a good chunk of willpower to finish it)
Prince of Persia: Two Thrones (made me feel glad that i finish WW, satisfying conclusion to the three part game)
Resident Evil 1 REmake (tank controls, brutal difficulty, hope you're a mashochist)
Resident Evil Zero (ditto)
Resident Evil 4 (assuming you don't have a wii)
Soul Calibur 2 (inclusion of link is reason enough)
Starfox Adventures (its like playing a furry link)
Starfox Assault (air missions = awesome, foot missions = teh sux)
Super Monkey Ball 2 (great for multiplayer)
Super Smash Bros Melee (need i say more?)
Tales of Symphonia (great RPG, story is a bit cliche, but hey its a good game)
Viewtiful Joe (love this game, its like capcom took everything awesome about a beat'em up, added flash and more substance, and thats viewtiful joe)
Viewtiful Joe 2 (pretty good sequel, more save points strewn about)[/QUOTE]
I actually printed this list and will use it when I go to stores. I've bought about a dozen games so far, and will kill Ebgames when the have the B2g1 deal. Thanks for all the info everyone!