[quote name='dmaul1114']
Gears 2 has that spot now for the campaign (have beaten in 3 times--casual by myself then hardcore and insane with my roommate in co-op). I love the Gears games, so I doubt anything will surpass it. Fallout 3 (which I have on the shelf waiting more free time, probably has the best chance. Playing Fable 2 and like it a lot, but not as much, and I don't see myself like L4D more. And that's probably all the 2008 games I'll play that I haven't yet unless something is slipping my mind.[/QUOTE]
Oh, also will play Prince of Persia...forgot about it until I saw e-mail from Goozex saying it was on the way. But I don't think that's remotely a GotY contender.
[quote name='ninja dog']That's a tough one, but I think you're on to something. I loved every last minute of ME, but slogged through those last few hours of Bioshock. can't bring myself back to do an "evil" run.
[/QUOTE]
ME was my GotY for 2007 too. But it was a tough call as I loved Bioshock. And Call of Duty 4. And Halo 3. Was a hell of a year for games.
Also have never done the evil run of Bioshock or a 2nd playthrough of ME yet. Just hard to get motivated to replay games with limited time. Would generally rather play something for the first time.