[quote name='bigdaddybruce44']I always love when someone thinks their opinion of a game means more than just about everyone else's. "Oh, I loved this game. All of the reviewers who said it was shit are just out-of-touch." "This game blows. It just got good reviews, because of the hype." Is it just possible that you like a bad game or you hate a good game?[/QUOTE]
My complaint against game critics was not at all rooted in any single review. This isn't about just Prototype. All of my favorite games tend to get mediocre reviews, and this is true of most people I know... and one trend I've noticed, those favorite games are usually pretty unoriginal. They're often just improved versions of borrowed ideas (Prototype) or sequels similar to their predecessors (Madden 10).
My theory is that the reason game critics value presentation and innovation so much is because they're jaded. It definitely stands to reason that hardcore gamers, gamers who regularly spend several hours per week playing games, some of them several hours per day, would have a very different opinion of unoriginal games than people who haven't played a ton of games. It stands to reason that someone with extensive experience playing Hulk, GTA, True Crime, Crackdown, Infamous, Godfather, etc, is going to have a very different opinion of Prototype than someone who isn't yet tired of that game design...
Before dismissing my comments as the rantings of some indignant jackass maybe you should step back and ask yourself if your assessment of games isn't affected by how many other games you play... you have a gamer score of 48,000... how many people do you think play as many games as you?