[quote name='elmyra']Like Benjamouth, I agree with your basic premise, but the above is just ridiculous. You complained about a fallacious argument in your first paragraph and then did the exact thing you complained about in the next paragraph. Forza 2, Project Gotham Racing 3, Crackdown, Saints Row, Dead or Alive 4, Dead Rising (which you did mention) and Viva Pinata all reviewed well based on
Game Rankings averages. Most of them also sold very well (only DoA4 and Viva aren't million sellers). None of them are first-person shooters, and they also cover diverse genres. But you certainly were clever about it, pick your nose and give someone the finger, hah![/QUOTE]
I know that the 360 has a lot of good exclusive games (I don't do racers so much, but that and DOA4 aside, I own the games listed above). I think I was merely pointing out that when asked to name the 360's biggest (the "AAA," if you will) titles that give it an advantage over other consoles, Halo, Bioshock, and GoW are the most frequently mentioned. The system IS FPS heavy (but that may also be the direction the industry is heading, I suppose, as neither the Wii or PS3 are starved for them, either).
It's a weak argument (christ I'm hungover today and not really in the mood to discuss this ad nauseum as I typically would), but those other exclusive games are not, by themselves, system sellers. I think that's what separates the three FPS club: people DID buy new consoles for Halo 3, they surely will for GoW2, and...well, the jury's out on Bioshock, but a lack of multiplayer ain't going to do it any good as a system seller. The other games above, however, aren't going to cause a spike or surge in new system sales, IMO. Somebody (in this thread?) pointed out that 360s seem to die off at a much more noticeable and prominent rate when big games come out - GHII, GoW, Halo 3 - and that it's likely not because of bad discs/"killer" games, but, rather, that more people are playing their console more frequently (and that the seemingly higher death rate is an artifact of more people using their consoles).
...where was I? Oh. Perhaps Forza is a system seller by itself, but I don't see DOA, Viva Pinata, or Saints Row as pushing consoles out the door. They are useful, though...if you notice some of the more refined "PS3 has no games" arguers, you'll see that they're willing to drop $400/500 for a console when it has a number of games worth playing, rather than 2 or 3 they *might* play. So the list as you have it is a solid library, but individually, they're not "blockbusters."
[quote name='wwe101']lets face it. the only thing that can stop the ps3 from completly failing is to drop the price to atleast $399, lose that blu ray format and stick an HD drive in there so developers can make the games faster (they are having some trouble putting the games on the blu rays). ohh and one more thing, A HUGE ASS LIST OF EXCLUSIVES. wait let me rephrase that, A HUGE ASS LIST OF GOOD EXCLUSIVES.:lol:[/QUOTE]
Don't drink and surf. Take an advil, go to bed, wake up, and then surf.