Yeah, I bought the Elemental CE on eBay a few years ago and asked the Stardock folks around the time that the first iteration of FE was coming out about getting the free upgrade they were offering to owners of Elemental and was told that my purchase was too recent to qualify for it. That wouldn't bother me so much if they hadn't essentially quit supporting Elemental as soon as FE was published. The history of these games is really unusual for Stardock, which did have a pretty stellar track record of supporting its releases until the half-baked abortion that was Elemental was actually released. Fallen Enchantress was created as a kind of mulligan, which I get (the dev for that dinosaur shooter that's on free for this week did basically the same thing), but now Wardell and Stardock are just trying to pretend that it just flat-out never happened. If you go to the game's
homepage, you can see that there is now no reference at all to the original game. Unlike the Orion: Dino Horde situation though, it's a little harder to pretend a thing never existed that you created a physical boxed version and a collector's edition of.
I hope this whole Fallen Enchantress thing represents a fluke in game production and marketing from SD, but I have serious doubts about that. I have a feeling the company's not making that much money on its software products now that Windows 7/8 have made them considerably less useful and the only really big positive on their rep chart at this point is their relationship with Ironclad; Sins of a Solar Empire was very well-received, although, again, Rebellion was mostly just the base game with a few added factions and the improvements from the expansion packs that were already released and sold separately, instead of including the long-awaited campaign mode (Wardell is also on the record as hating single-player campaigns).