[quote name='NJMane']Agreed with the whole "Brand New" thing. List it as "Like New".
Also $8.00 for shipping is a bit excessive.[/quote]
Normally I would agree with you on the shipping, but there are a few things to consider. Priority mail rates just went up, so he's only ahead a few bucks on the shipping. I think (and this has already been debated before) that $2 to $3 is okay for time, gas, etc. Others would disagree, but it probably isn't excessive enough to have his auction pulled.
Now the guys charging $20 to ship a game? That's excessive.