GTA SA review from GameSpot!

A 9.9? Very impressive, but like swetooth said its one of those games where you don't need to read a review-you know its going to be amazing.
 
[quote name='basketkase543']Wow, IGN gave it a 9.9! That's the highest score i've seen from them in a LONG time.[/quote]


I wonder what the negative .1 was for?
 
[quote name='munch'][quote name='basketkase543']Wow, IGN gave it a 9.9! That's the highest score i've seen from them in a LONG time.[/quote]


I wonder what the negative .1 was for?[/quote]
No game is perfect.
 
[quote name='Bann'][quote name='munch'][quote name='basketkase543']Wow, IGN gave it a 9.9! That's the highest score i've seen from them in a LONG time.[/quote]


I wonder what the negative .1 was for?[/quote]
No game is perfect.[/quote]

IGN gave almost every GB Pokemon game a 10. IGN scores suck donkey dick IMO.
 
[quote name='Bann'][quote name='munch'][quote name='basketkase543']Wow, IGN gave it a 9.9! That's the highest score i've seen from them in a LONG time.[/quote]


I wonder what the negative .1 was for?[/quote]
No game is perfect.[/quote]

i beg to differ:
197771_n64.jpg

http://www.gamespot.com/n64/adventure/legendofzeldaoot/index.html?q=zelda
 
[quote name='Bann'][quote name='munch'][quote name='Bann'][quote name='munch'][quote name='basketkase543']Wow, IGN gave it a 9.9! That's the highest score i've seen from them in a LONG time.[/quote]


I wonder what the negative .1 was for?[/quote]
No game is perfect.[/quote]

i beg to differ:
197771_n64.jpg

http://www.gamespot.com/n64/adventure/legendofzeldaoot/index.html?q=zelda[/quote]
According to gamespot. I wonder if there wasn't a little hype surrounding the first 3-D Zelda?[/quote]

I must agree, it was good but snes Zelda is still the best
 
[quote name='zionoverfire'][quote name='Bann'][quote name='munch'][quote name='Bann'][quote name='munch'][quote name='basketkase543']Wow, IGN gave it a 9.9! That's the highest score i've seen from them in a LONG time.[/quote]


I wonder what the negative .1 was for?[/quote]
No game is perfect.[/quote]

i beg to differ:
197771_n64.jpg

http://www.gamespot.com/n64/adventure/legendofzeldaoot/index.html?q=zelda[/quote]
According to gamespot. I wonder if there wasn't a little hype surrounding the first 3-D Zelda?[/quote]

I must agree, it was good but snes Zelda is still the best[/quote]

Yes but ATTP is also "10" worthy.

Just put in 5 straight hrs into GTASA, something I haven't done in a long, long time.

No doubt: GOTY (IMO)
 
[quote name='zionoverfire'][quote name='Bann'][quote name='munch'][quote name='Bann'][quote name='munch'][quote name='basketkase543']Wow, IGN gave it a 9.9! That's the highest score i've seen from them in a LONG time.[/quote]


I wonder what the negative .1 was for?[/quote]
No game is perfect.[/quote]

i beg to differ:
197771_n64.jpg

http://www.gamespot.com/n64/adventure/legendofzeldaoot/index.html?q=zelda[/quote]
According to gamespot. I wonder if there wasn't a little hype surrounding the first 3-D Zelda?[/quote]

I must agree, it was good but snes Zelda is still the best[/quote]

OOT is the best Zelda game, ALTTP is the worst.
 
[quote name='ChrisXE']I beg to differ, another perfect score from gamespot

http://www.gamespot.com/ps/rpg/chronocross/index.html[/quote]Yes, we know. Everyone is begging to differ. :wink:

Alot of games have gotten perfect 10s from many places. It's not that amazing. No game may be completely perfect, but truly great games that may have a few small errors still deserve a perfect score, IMO.
 
I never really understood IGN's score system with their "not an average" comment. I saw a review just recently where all the individual scores were 8.0 but they gave the game an 8.4 overall rating......
 
[quote name='Jaxcomet']I never really understood IGN's score system with their "not an average" comment. I saw a review just recently where all the individual scores were 8.0 but they gave the game an 8.4 overall rating......[/quote]

Ever hear the expression "greater than the sum of its parts"? That's just so a game that has a certain single flaw or whatever won't drag the score all down.

Think the Beatles--as a group they'd be a 10 but if you rated each guy separate they wouldn't all be 10 (as their solo careers certainly showed).

[quote name='zionoverfire']well I'm glad the reviews are good. I'm sorry but after State of Emergency I won't buy a rockstar game until I've read a few reviews.[/quote]

Rockstar didn't develop that they only published it. And the only non-GTA game that Rockstar North has developed is Manhunt.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
bread's done
Back
Top