[quote name='-Never4ever-']exactly how was signs stupid, cause maddox said so?
Am I the only person left that doesn't follow the "crowd"
Signs being leaked a week before released did hurt it's box office, thinking otherwise is retarded. that's like saying VG piracy has zero impact on VG sales.

[/quote]
Virtually every film in the last five years has been in illicit circulation before its release. I've found VCD's of major film at swap meets on the same weekend they opened with a level of quality beyond what can be achieved by pointing a handheld camera at a theater screen.
In spite of this plenty of films have done massive box office. The take on popular films has been growing at a rate greater than inflation. If piracy is having a major impact on opening week box office receipts, which is the most profitable part of a film's theatrical run, it has yet to be demonstrated in any statistical analysis based on number of available venues and other contributing factors.
I watched 'Signs' when it came around on cable and it was every bit as bad as I expected. Very good production values and good actors but an awful screenplay with some very odd Old Testament manner to how it dispensed death and survival.
But most important of all was that the critical selling point of the movie was crop circles. I can't take any movie seriously if it purports to take crop circles seriously. I meet too many reality challenged idiots in real life who buy into such crap being anything other than simple pranksters to spend my money on a movie delivering the same insult.
I'd never seen that Maddox comic strip until just a few minutes ago but it's pretty accurate. It just goes to show the power of good movie making to cloud viewer's minds. I saw the ending of 'Sixth Sense' coming after the first reel but enjoyed the trip. It was a long form version of a Twilight Zone episode and a fairly old concept. The trick in 'Sixth Sense' was in not making the audience grow impatient waiting for Rod Serling to do a concluding voiceover and let them leave. 'Unbreakable' was great for treating the concept of the superhero from a different angle and making it fit in a believably real world. Making a superhero work outside of a SFX extravaganza was an ingenius feat.
Shyamalan has a tendency to shoplift from sources mainstream theater audiences won't recognize. The Sam Jackson character in 'Unbreakable' has a fragile bone disease inspired by a great Walt Simonson storyline in 'Thor.' Shyamalan acknowledges this by actually putting a Thor issue in Jackson's hand in one scene.
The dead man who doesn't accept his own death has been done many times and I've little doubt he's familiar with Jim Starlin's Dreadstar comic book series which had a similar character in the form of a wizard who had been fatally injured in the process of acquiring great power but remained alive after a fashion by sheer force of will and lots of prosthetics.
There was a great scene in one issue where the title character began to suspect the severity of his friend's condition. They are each standing on opposite sides of a pond. Dreadstar has a vision in which he sees Syzygy's reflection as the rotting corpse he really is. He mentions this to another friend who says he realized the truth long ago due to his much stronger sense of smell. When Dreadstar trie to ask Syzygy what this means he is cut off and told, "Belief is a very fragile thing. Just a word can destroy it." From then on he leaves well enough alone.