I received mines today ordered 3/29/08 received in the mail at about 10am 4/2/08
it came by Fed Ex
tin case has a ding in the upper right corner thats it, some color faded from casing most likely due to sliding in and out of the sleeve, also a little on the top and bottom of casing guessing its from sitting on a metal shelf in their stores or something
manual has some wear on it, not that bad since its a different color from the original halo 3 manual so you cant really tell
poster had wear all over the edges, as if someone has the case and just kept shaking it around with the poster inside of it
bonus art book came in excellent conition (like new)
now for the discs, well both disc were loose from the spindle when they arrived (not in sleeves)
amazingly they look the same way they'd look as if you bought them on day one
yes, i've seen how the disc look on day one when halo 3 was released
that means all the scratches and and everything from the faulty packaging or the spindle, whatever caused the scratches, but all in all great deal, i'll be testing the disc in the next few days to make sure everything is ok