I don't go into restaurants like Outback Steak house and warn the customers that for that same $25 they are gonna spend on a meal, they could get 22 cheeseburgers, fries, apple pie and coke from McDonalds. Know why? Because for them, there is value in the steak.
Debate it to death, but the PSN or Wii Online experienced is currently not up to par with that of the Xbox 360. Does this mean that XBL Gold is worth $30 a year? (assuming look for deals) Well, that is once again a question of relative values. To me, I think it is dumb that people are constantly buying up cheap games for $1-$10 on this site, only to have them sit in a corner of their house, or maybe only play them for a few hours, max. But, you don't see my running into their threads and dropping a big stinker of a post, now do you?
And about DLC - it prolongs the life of the game, but once again, it's value is relative. To me, I buy 1 or 2 multiplayer-centric games a year. That's it. The competitive multipalyer experience offered by games like Halo or CoD are more than enough to satiate my gaming desires. Maybe that isn't what floats your boat, maybe you would rather play jRPGs or Pokemon games - but im not going to sit here and insult you for playing what you like.
As it stands, Reach will probably be a game I will continue to play for 2-3 years, consistently. The game mode that I will be playing almost always will be Arena or some other team slayer variant. There will also be hundreds of thousands of other people with the same exact intentions. Excuse us for not wanting to play the same 6 maps (because atleast 2 of those will be too big for team slayer) for 2 to 3 years. Not to mention, about 2 of those 6 maps will be stinkers. And to anyone who says that Forge World will provide a plethora of new maps for the matchmaking experience - you're only half right. The lack of different textures pieces in Forge has always been a glaring issue. Forge World maps will be fun, but they will not last as long as the maps such as the Ivory tower remake.
Remember, gaming, especially online gaming is a hobby - a diversion from real life - NOT a job. You don't have to play online. If you're too cheap to shell out the $10 for periodic map packs to extend the life of your favorite game, then you shouldn't be playing online. And to those of you claiming Bungie "locks you out" for not buying the DLC, you still ahve a few palylists to play in, and since you aren't such an avid player, it shouldn't matter anyway. Bungie shouldn't penalize us people who buy the maps just because a few people didn't want to buy the maps, or else you end up in a situation like halo 2 where I am buying maps that HARDLY ever come up in Ranked team slayer.