[quote name='Slim Gatsby']This, pretty much. Especially hand-drawn animation, like old 80's cartoons, etc. Even on SD-DVDs, you can see tons of dust on the cells and all of those little errors. Unless the studios spend a lot of money cleaning things up -- and they won't -- it will likely look worse in HD, as opposed to looking the same as SD.
And another thing that's being forgotten here: its all about resolution. Line-art with flat colors and cell-shading isn't going to benefit. Newer computer-animated films look great in HD, but that's because detailed texturing, etc., is a big part of the technique.[/quote]
Thank you.
Many of us didn't notice the animation errors or the dust/dandruff/specks when we watched the first broadcast. 20+ years later the stuff is now noticable. It would probably cost the studio tens of thosands of dollars to go back and clean up each episode, a cost that would no doubt be passed on to us in the final package... so a remastered, cleaned up to near perfection season 1 of transformers for 100 dollars or find the first run discs for 40 bucks.
I just got my first LCD HDTV the other day and playing SD-DVDs on it makes it look worse on a 16x9 HDTV.
Having the episodes on one disc IS technically possible on a quad layer BR disc and encoding the video using better encoding techniques, but it's not going to look any better.