[quote name='gizmogc']I don't think any store lets you return strategy guides or even magazines. They are meant t be read and thrown away. Who knows that you didn't just read it, beat the game, now want money back? I think its 100% fair. Would you want to goto EB and buy a used game marked as new? No, everyone hear bitches about it.
Seriously, the only way they will let you return it is if a manager is nice and allows it. I know I would never let anyone return a magazine or strategy guide.[/quote]
You are forgetting that people are free to read before they are buying the guide, so it is never as new as you think. A better example would be compare it to other bookstores. Many will let you retrun even with slight wear. Plus often I brought guides that are not "new" to begin with.
The manger might have his own option on the issue, but he can't let that interfer with the store policy.
As for the decison of the manger, I often met manager who were willing to bend the rules. Those ended up being places that I prefer to spend my money at.