[quote name='AugustAPC']It's not really driving me crazy, lol. I was exaggerating. But it does piss me off that I

ed up my cover. I emailed SquareEnix, so we'll see what happens there (though my hopes aren't really that high). I display my CE's, so it does kinda suck, like a stain on your favorite shirt or something.
I guess I'll ask at GameStop next time I'm in there... as stated earlier, it doesn't hurt.
I'm sure eventually I'll be able to replace it, I just hope it's sooner, rather than later.
Anyway, did anyone else notice this sticker on their CEs?[/QUOTE]
That would drive me nuts... seriously, I've good money money for some replacement boxes that I didn't like.

Of course, it depends on how much I like the game.
Back to the issue at hand, I don't think GS will help. Normally, they only do exchanges for opened, non-functional games. And when you do go in for an exchange, they'll just swap your disc out with the one from the gutted copy and put your disc in place of the gutted one (yeah, so they basically pass on the problem)... unless the disc is known to be damaged because of a poorly designed case or something. If they have no more copies, then they'll send you to another store.
I guess your one final alternative is to sell the entire set and then hope that it eventually goes on sale.