[quote name='banpeikun']The one I got from GS last thanksgiving had a really messed up manual. It looked like someone spilled some water on it, then ate a chocolate donut and wiped their finger on it, then put it out in the sun. Anyone want to trade a mint one for it???

[/QUOTE]
Haha tha'ts hilarious. Actually My disk has 3 small sticky "finger print" it seems like some sugar stain to me. I was able to wipe it clean though.
I don't get how ppl treat their games, maybe they just don't care, but whenever i opened up my games, just looking at the shining case, un-wrinkled manual, i always handle it extremely careful even if i intend to trade in later. It's that feeling of "wow it's nice, i better not ruin it"
I remember when i traded in FFIII SNES into EBgames... I had EVERYTHING. the map that came with, the stupid nintendo warning thing... manaul was like untouched, original plastic bag. This was after like 6 or 7 years after I bought the game. if you shrink wrap it back this game can almost be call brand new (but the cartridge has saves on it of course) The EB guy was like.. "dude did you even play this game at all?"
I am such a fleabay noob, got outbid like 4 times for Ikaruga at last sec. But now with this somewhat "ebay experience" i will be considering Ebay my FFVII which is again, looks competely brand new. HAHA.... perfect case, no scratches, manaul seems untouched again.. and i'ts the first print none GH version. Along with brand-new-looking collector edition N64 zelda Ocarina of time with the special golden bag + sticker + poster if you pre-order from EB... Interesting.
Nobody plays import SNES or genesis game here eh? What a shame consider i have tons of those that are brand new looking too. I bet it's rare as hell but 0 value-wise.