I've stuck with Gamefly ever since my local Hollywood Video and Blockbuster closed down. Like many have said, if you can finish the game in less than a week, it is totally worth it. I have found it perfect for games like Child of Eden and Homefront, but not for games like Fallout or Mass Effect. Also, when you learn how long it takes for them to get a game, you can plan ahead and get new games. Personally, if I had a new "coming soon" game in my queue and an open shipping slot on Monday, I was pretty much guaranteed that new game to ship. Finally, something I haven't seen mentioned, but happens to me all the time, is that sometimes, when I ship a game back, before they even receive the physical copy of the game I sent back, they will have already shipped me another game in my queue (I currently have the 1 game out plan). I think I read somewhere that some post offices scan the envelopes so Gamefly knows when a game is on its way back and will send you another one to cut down on waiting time. While I won't recommend it for everyone, for a broke college student who learned how to manage the shipping times, it is perfect for the new releases I don't plan on purchasing but don't want to wait for a price drop (which, nowadays, seems to be about a week). All I can say is go hit up the free stuff forum, find one of the codes that gives you two months for the price of one, and give it a shot. If you don't like it, it is quite easy to terminate your subscription.